The NBA Thread

I understand your take in regards to 3 and would have been 1000% fine with SGA winning it but...

Every single player?

I'd have him above KD / Dirk and on par with Shaq. I didn't watch Moses. Obviously, his career is not done and I do think he is going to wear down quicker than people think due to the burden of being an heliocentric hub at 300 lbs. He's already started dealing with back problems this year.

That said, this four year peak is up there with almost any other player I've watched post-Jordon. And every other single player on your list played with multiple all-stars. Jokic hasn't even played with an all-defensive player much less another all-star.

I personally believe Jamal was becoming somewhere between a Mitchell and Booker level player but he tore his ACL, in large part, because of the shortened offseason after the bubble. We were also trashing the rest of the West that season after making the AG trade and looked really, really dangeous.

Jamal has been healthy exactly 2 post-seasons out of the past 5. And those 2 years we made the WCF and won a chip. It falls apart without him because the entire system is built around the two man game and there is a derth of shot creation outside of them.

If Mal can't stay healthy next year, I honestly hope Jokic asks out- something I never thought I'd say- because I can already see this is going to be the common take once he's retired. A different, worse flavor of the Nash convo.

Also, Embid has played with Butler, Harden and Maxey. Plus, Ben when he was racking up all-stars and DPOY chatter. That's four all-stars, two HoF and one of the best playoff risers in NBA history.... and still hasn't made it out of the 2nd round.

He does not belong in the same historical breath as Jokic and Giannis anymore than Ewing does Hakeem.
I think that last point is spot on, I think in all reality that Hakeem/Robinson/Ewing is a good comparison point for Jokic/Giannis/Embiid in terms of relative positioning on all time rankings and how we may remember this era.
 
Sorry, yes. I got my years mixed up. If Giannis had two, Embiid had two and Jokić had two it would paint a better picture of the era, in my opinion. I don’t feel like any at this point should have 3.
My bad, my reading comprehension skills suck after the long work day/beers. Totally agree on this but the lack of playoff success for Embiid, who is a great talent, affects his place among the era’s greats. But all three are pretty extraordinary
 
Back
Top