When I was oiling mine honest Amish products were solid
Needles & Grooves
bdm105
Melt Face Molly Drop
Au naturale baby. Keep em prickly like a cactus
HayesWeighsIn
O'Douds!
dhodo
Haven't been using it as much as I should lately, but my favorite that I've tried is Badger beard balm. I liked the Honest Amish beard balm too. Generally prefer the not too waxy balms over oils personally since it tames the crazy hairs a tiny bit more than oil without "styling." And less likely to drip on my shirt if I'm clumsy!
debianlinux
Seconding Badger
TenderLovingKiller®
Whatever's cheapest. I haven't found there to be too big of a difference, They are have a pretty similar make up.