Vinyl Me Please (store, exclusives, swaps, etc)

I’m not agreeing with him. I see no benefit in that plan, it will always be cheaper to be a member because you get records and a bigger discount. But I think giving them anymore than a month’s worth of money at this point is a poor financial decision and. Giving them free money is a worse decision.
If you’re a member on a longer sub (and for some reason don’t ask for a refund) I think the move might be to swap for credit and then keep rolling it over on one month subs or use it to buy the store exclusives. It’s basically a free/cheap crate membership
 
I mean the timing is fishy. They suddenly say they have a big change coming in January after only announcing the first record of Q1. Then when they make the announcement it turns out there isn’t a record for February.
Eh I don’t think it’s all that fishy. They knew the change was coming. They weren’t gonna announce that 3 months in advance. They likely realized that with the delays and financial issues that all this stuff was untenable to keep monthly ROTMs going on 3 tracks.

So I’d bet they probably chose the album they had licensed already that would sell best to launch this “new experience”
 
Eh I don’t think it’s all that fishy. They knew the change was coming. They weren’t gonna announce that 3 months in advance. They likely realized that with the delays and financial issues that all this stuff was untenable to keep monthly ROTMs going on 3 tracks.

So I’d bet they probably chose the album they had licensed already that would sell best to launch this “new experience”
Dude. If it had been planned well (I’m not necessarily saying they forgot), they would have announced the plan instead of a record. It would have made more sense to announce it when there was a full slate instead of causing another big uproar and then classics being 3 MONTHS off from being available for the plan and the first one issued.

As to Rocket to Russia and stuff. I’ve said my piece. Allowing swaps on add ons was a bad idea when they announced it. Quickest way to shore everything up was to do away with that bad practice. Just because customers like something doesn’t mean it’s a good business idea.

They are an unserious business doing unserious things.
 
Dude. If it had been planned well (I’m not necessarily saying they forgot), they would have announced the plan instead of a record. It would have made more sense to announce it when there was a full slate instead of causing another big uproar and then classics being 3 MONTHS off from being available for the plan and the first one issued.

As to Rocket to Russia and stuff. I’ve said my piece. Allowing swaps on add ons was a bad idea when they announced it. Quickest way to shore everything up was to do away with that bad practice. Just because customers like something doesn’t mean it’s a good business idea.

They are an unserious business doing unserious things.
But the issue is that there IS no full slate right now. Which is why they are not doing ROTMs anymore haha. Supposedly they will try to announce 2-3 true exclusives each month as preorders and hope to make it eventually so they are in stock to order instead of preorder.

I never said it was a good plan. As others said, if you need that gigantic wall of text to explain what the new "experience" is and it STILL doesn't make sense after reading it twice... then maybe its not a good plan.

I agree that adding swaps on add-ons was a bad idea for them as a business. They kept adding more and more factors to make inventory and orders hard to manage. There is so much about their business and how it is run that makes no sense. Don't get me started about how bad the website is and how its held together by bandaids and spreadsheets that have to be manually updated.
 
That’s what I was saying all along. The timing is suspect. They ran out of ROTM ready to go. Shut can we make this new plan work next week? I don’t know. Fuck. What do we do? Announce January and let’s beta test and pray.
Wouldn't be shocked if some titles got pulled from them for not paying the labels or they were worried they wouldn't sell and stopped production. The titles were licensed already for Jan/Feb/March. The hints were in the mag and titles were confirmed by staff on discord.

I just don't think this was a spur of the moment decision for them. The beta testing was done months ago to set all this up. I bet they reached a point where they decided that they just can't afford to press the ROTM quantities they were doing for even 3 tracks anymore and didn't have much of a financial runway so they axed the ROTMs they had planned with big runs and pivoted.

Those 12 month subs with 8 bonus records all ran out by now and I'd be they were hoping more people would stick around. But with all the issues lately, I bet the large majority of those jumped ship.

The bigger problem is that they have alienated long term subscribers. Even some of the most loyal VMP stans on the discord won't re-sub. They've catered to newer subscribers with this new plan (pick up our back catalogue instead of a new ROTM). But the newer subscribers are all having a shit time with the service with the delays for preorders and fulfillment. my money is on them just becoming a reissue label and doing away with subs altogether by later this year if they make it that far.

Goes without saying, but I wouldn't invest any kind of real long-term money with them. I'm gonna burn the rest of my credit hopefully soon, or keep a sub and just roll it over with swap for credit each month. I'm just playing with house money now.
 
If you’re a member on a longer sub (and for some reason don’t ask for a refund) I think the move might be to swap for credit and then keep rolling it over on one month subs or use it to buy the store exclusives. It’s basically a free/cheap crate membership
I missed this nugget in the FAQs, "if you wish to cancel your membership and get a pro-rated refund (either for store credit or back to your original payment method)"

I thought cancellations could only be issued as store credit.
 
I missed this nugget in the FAQs, "if you wish to cancel your membership and get a pro-rated refund (either for store credit or back to your original payment method)"

I thought cancellations could only be issued as store credit.
I believe you only have until some time in early February to do this. I don't think they will refund cash if you use store/member credit of course.

If i was an international member, it would be a no-brainer to get a refund. If for some reason I just resubbed for a year as a domestic subscriber, I'd get my money back. Then maybe use the Creem deal and JOINTHECLUB20 to get 20% off a shorter sub and 3 free back catalogue records and roll over my sub to credit each month to keep a membership in case something popped up that i wanted.

Or....there are plenty of other cool subscription services out there to support that do cool releases, get stuff out on time and have some great and interesting music for cheaper. Shoutout Mississippi Records subscription and Tipitinas.
 
I missed this nugget in the FAQs, "if you wish to cancel your membership and get a pro-rated refund (either for store credit or back to your original payment method)"

I thought cancellations could only be issued as store credit.
Given the change in terms of the subscription, they pretty much have to offer a refund since this is not what you signed up for or what they promised when you paid them. They give a date so they can say that silence as of that date in February implies consent with the changes. I think it is a no-brainer for everyone to seek a refund at this point.

This has restructuring/bankruptcy written all over it. Just look at the bandbox saga.
 
Also my reading was that the company doesn’t wanna do away with swap for credit either. It didn’t even seem like those convos had come up. Swap for credit is a goldmine for them. They get money and don’t have to ship anything out 😂😂
I would think the swap for credit is a liability. Look at all of these folks with hundreds in unusable credits (nothing worth buying) sitting around bitching now. If VMP folds, there's going to be legal fights for that credit to be refunded i.e. debt. If VMP is stuck unable to fulfill existing orders due to a lack of cash flow, but they owe people either product or cash back, that's a problem. Credits are money paid up front i.e. loaned to VMP without fulfillment if unused.

If you "close the loop" with each customer transaction- they either buy something by choice, VMP picks something for the customer, or you don't buy anything--then you don't have these piles of credit, it's cleaner if they are forced to close. Also easier to deal with Shopify and accounting-wise, rather than tracking all these credits year over year.

I am surprised they haven't had limits around credit, such as it must be used by end of each year or if they could, they'll refund it.
 
All this VMP doomer discourse has me wonderin' ...

How many of us former VMPers who joined Needles & Grooves after they shuttered the discussion board ever thought N&G would outlive VMP?

What VMP album will get your first spin after they fold?

I'll probably start with Fiona Apple - Tidal (followed by the Blue Note Anthology)
 
All this VMP doomer discourse has me wonderin' ...

How many of us former VMPers who joined Needles & Grooves after they shuttered the discussion board ever thought N&G would outlive VMP?

What VMP album will get your first spin after they fold?

I'll probably start with Fiona Apple - Tidal (followed by the Blue Note Anthology)
I figured this forum would last longer than VMP, but to watch VMP crash and burn like they have has been the surprise. They never ran an efficient business but man they truly turned out to be inept as they continued to grow. I'm shocked how many people here still give them a single solitary dollar knowing what we've all known for well over a year now. I'll spin Ready to Die when they make the announcement that they are shutting down officially since that title is fitting.
 
I would think the swap for credit is a liability. Look at all of these folks with hundreds in unusable credits (nothing worth buying) sitting around bitching now. If VMP folds, there's going to be legal fights for that credit to be refunded i.e. debt. If VMP is stuck unable to fulfill existing orders due to a lack of cash flow, but they owe people either product or cash back, that's a problem. Credits are money paid up front i.e. loaned to VMP without fulfillment if unused.

If you "close the loop" with each customer transaction- they either buy something by choice, VMP picks something for the customer, or you don't buy anything--then you don't have these piles of credit, it's cleaner if they are forced to close. Also easier to deal with Shopify and accounting-wise, rather than tracking all these credits year over year.

I am surprised they haven't had limits around credit, such as it must be used by end of each year or if they could, they'll refund it.
I wouldn’t sit on hundreds in credit (which is why I said if you have a year long sub get your money back), but I don’t think one month’s credit is a liability. All depends on your situation IMO. They have had enough stuff for me the past few months to use credit on. I’m in a bit of different situation given mine were referral credits. I also like most of the jazz stuff they put out so can usually find something to pick up over time.

Many of the people complaining about credit are international subscribers who can’t use credit on preorders, can’t use credit to add months to their sub, etc. which is of course a very valid reason to be upset.

Assume as much risk as you feel comfortable with.
 
. If VMP folds, there's going to be legal fights for that credit to be refunded i.e. debt. If VMP is stuck unable to fulfill existing orders due to a lack of cash flow, but they owe people either product or cash back, that's a problem. Credits are money paid up front i.e. loaned to VMP without fulfillment if unused.
Also if VMP folds, customers aren’t gonna get shit back. Members can sue all they want but they are at the very long line list of creditors if they go under. See: bandbox. Banks, investors, pressing plants, labels, artists will all be ahead of customers who lost a few hundred bucks. For bandbox, the artists and pressing plants never got paid. Customers didn’t get a cent back and never will (aside from those who were able to do chargebacks)
 
Given the change in terms of the subscription, they pretty much have to offer a refund since this is not what you signed up for or what they promised when you paid them. They give a date so they can say that silence as of that date in February implies consent with the changes. I think it is a no-brainer for everyone to seek a refund at this point.

This has restructuring/bankruptcy written all over it. Just look at the bandbox saga.
You are 100% correct.

1000006333.gif
 
All this VMP doomer discourse has me wonderin' ...

How many of us former VMPers who joined Needles & Grooves after they shuttered the discussion board ever thought N&G would outlive VMP?

What VMP album will get your first spin after they fold?

I'll probably start with Fiona Apple - Tidal (followed by the Blue Note Anthology)
I just pulled my VMP exclusive of Dan Deacan’s Spiderman Of The Rings off the self yesterday for the first time in an while and it reminded me what VMP could do when things were rolling. Great jacket with lots of sharp details the albums sounds great too. It’s such a a nice package and one they you could pick up as a swaption for under $30. They have always had random issues of varying degrees but when they do an album right they really did fill a nice hole in the industry.
 
All this VMP doomer discourse has me wonderin' ...

How many of us former VMPers who joined Needles & Grooves after they shuttered the discussion board ever thought N&G would outlive VMP?

What VMP album will get your first spin after they fold?

I'll probably start with Fiona Apple - Tidal (followed by the Blue Note Anthology)

I was lurking on the old forum for like 8 months before finally commenting. I’ll play the ROTM for the guess thread where I made my first comment, Moby’s Play. Or I’ll go with Feist which is easily my favorite album that VMP introduced me to
 
Back
Top