I didn't feel like starting a whole new thread just for this, but has it already been 2 months since these 2 Grado carts showed up? Hope you enjoy the read, just thought I would share.
View attachment 71308
Over the last 7 weeks or so I’ve been burning in and spinning away with my Grado Gold v3 and Grado ME+ Mono carts, after approx. 30 hours on each we started doing a little A/B testing to see what’s what with a mono cart on a “mono” pressing compared to a stereo cart on a mono pressing. A couple of quick disclaimers here, I have maybe 2 actual mono pressings and the rest are “modern” mono represses and or re-issues. I know there’s a big conversation about “true” mono, so I wanted to get that out of the way. 2nd disclaimer, these are just my opinions not gospel and only intended as such, sharing experiences is a big part of this hobby in my opinion, you can always gain a little something from a lot of people.
So let’s talk sound, I've always really liked the way mono pressings sounded with my stereo carts, I thought they represented the music better, some say they don’t hear a difference and like everything it boils down to preferences. But, when comparing them head to head (Mono vs Stereo Cart), there is a noticeable difference between the two….in my opinion.
What we listened to:
- The Beach Boys – Pet Sounds [45 RPM AP Mono Pressing 2017]
- Blossom Dearie – ST [Verve/VMP Mono Pressing 2019]
- Frank Sinatra – In the Wee Small Hours [Capitol Records Mono repress 1956]
- Jefferson Airplane – Surrealistic Pillow [Mobile Fidelity 45 RPM Mono 2015]
- John Coltrane – Blue Train [Blue Note 75th Ann. Mono 2014]
- The Kinks – The Kinks Are The Village Green Preservation Society [Sanctuary Records Reissue Mono 2014]
- Lightnin' Slim* – Rooster Blues [Excello reissue Mono 2016]
- Robert Johnson – King of The Delta Blues Singers [Columbia/MOV Remaster, Reissue Mono 2013]
- Sonny Rollins – Saxophone Colossus [Prestige remaster Mono 2011]
After spending a lot of time going back and forth over single tracks at a time, I find it kind of easy to explain. The stereo cart, again, while sounding really good, has an extra airiness to it, which makes sense, but with the mono cart that disappears and the focus goes to what’s in the track, the instruments and the vocals. The instruments are more defined compared to the stereo cart, the bass is much tighter and “warmer”, it has a more detailed strum and thump to it. The vocals are accurate, very much how they should sound and “feel”. I fight the urge to say the difference is subtle, but subtle doesn’t always mean it’s not noticeable if that makes sense. That’s really it, I honestly think it’s the closest representation of how the music was meant to sound. I will add that pressing quality, as always, varies and does show on a mono cart as it does on any other cartridge you run.
Is it worth the hassle? Yes and no, and I’ll explain. If you don’t have a replaceable head shell, I would say no. Even though I really, really prefer the sound from the mono cart, it wouldn’t be worth the added work of mounting and calibrating a cart for just a couple albums. Maybe if you have a bigger mono collection, but even then, you need to stick to mono for a good stretch to avoid the inconvenience of switching back. Now, all that being said, if you have a removable head shell, I would really think about it, especially if you find yourself in a similar set up as I am, where you’re running a Grado cart already. With the Grado Prestige carts having the same specs and tracking force, the swap with a removable head shell is literally the same time it takes to flip an album.
I’m really happy I gave this a go and thrilled with the PLX 1000 set up with the Gold and ME+ carts on the fly for whatever I want to listen to. Yes, it’s $150 more for the ME+ and some of you with a Gold would probably appreciate the jump an 8MZ would bring to the table for the same cost, but as one of those always looking for the best representation of the music I listen to……..that I can afford, I’m really excited about quality mono pressings that might come along in the future.