dhodo
Well-Known Member
That review reads to me like they are mad it is a Naughty Dog 3rd person action/adventure game. They wanted it to be a Resident Evil survival game but also with innovative gameplay. Not sure why anyone would expect them to totally change the gameplay of the game it is a sequel to.Not to belabor the point, but the Vice review is also very negative. But it doesn't have a "number" so it won't be included in game scores.
Criticisms of the plot seem reasonable, but obviously are personal taste. Without a lot more details and probably spoilers, it's really hard for me to tell if I'll agree with the criticisms of the revenge plot lacking redeeming qualities or not. Sometimes a study of revenge without justification or redemption is still compelling.