I like it. I've been subbed for about a year now, maybe two albums I haven't liked, but those could sell on discogs or w/e (or PIF here) to turn them into something I do want. Plus the coffee is great.
This is their archive of most recent to oldet:
The Good Thing Archive
EDIT: Also worth noting that you get points for every purchase and on your birthday, I think every three months or so it turns into $5? Which basically amounts to a couple free bags of cofee per year.
Let me know if you plan to sign up, I think if I do a referral we both get $10