Rank The Albums!

My R.E.M. album ranking is something like this:

1. Murmur
2. Reckoning
3. Automatic For The People
4. New Adventures in Hi-Fi
5. Document
6. Lifes Rich Pageant
7. Fables Of The Reconstruction
8. Out Of Time
9. Monster
10. Green
11. Up
12. Reveal
13. Accelerate
14. Collapse Into Now
15. Around The Sun
 
avecigrec said:
R.E.M.


01. New Adventures in Hi-Fi
02. Chronic Town
03. Monster
04. Lifes Rich Pageant
05. Murmur
06. Document
07. Out of Time
08. Automatic For the People
09. Fables of the Reconstruction
10. Reckoning
11. Accelerate
12. Reveal
13. Up
14. Green
15. Around The Sun
16. Collapse Into Now
Click to expand...

TenderLovingKiller® said:
My R.E.M. ranked from top to bottom
Murmur
Reckoning
Automatic For The People
Life’s Rich Pageant
New Adventures In Hi-Fi
Document
Monster
Reveal
Up
Green
Fables Of The Reconstruction
Out Of Time
Accelerate
Collapse into Now
Around The Sun
Click to expand...

Wes C. Attle said:
I actually ranked REM in a Google notes and can’t remember if I actually ever posted it here:

1. Automatic For The People
2. Reckoning
3. Lifes Rich Pageant
4. Murmur
5. Chronic Town
6. New Adventures In Hi-Fi
7. Out Of Time
8. Green
9. Document
10. Fables Of The Reconstruction
11. Monster
12. Reveal
13. Up
14. Collapse Into Now
15. Accelerate
16. Around The Sun
Click to expand...

wmeugene said:
Here goes (almost all are essential and even last place is an album I appreciate):

1. Reckoning
2. Murmur
3. New Adventures in Hi-Fi
4. Document
5. Automatic For The People
6. Lifes Rich Pageant
7. Green
8. Fables of the Reconstruction
9. Chronic Town
10. Reveal
11. Accelerate
12. Out of Time
13. Monster
14. Up
15. Collapse Into Now
16. Around The Sun
Click to expand...

Hollywood said:
My R.E.M. album ranking is something like this:

1. Murmur
2. Reckoning
3. Automatic For The People
4. New Adventures in Hi-Fi
5. Document
6. Lifes Rich Pageant
7. Fables Of The Reconstruction
8. Out Of Time
9. Monster
10. Green
11. Up
12. Reveal
13. Accelerate
14. Collapse Into Now
15. Around The Sun
Click to expand...

I'm befuddled by how low Green is on these lists.
I would argue Green is the Most R.E.M. of all the R.E.M. releases, and the early attempt for their most artistic achievements.
Its Pollack's Mural before No. 5: they have the idea of where they are going but they haven't figured out exactly how to fully realize their potential

Pop Hit with lyrics that shouldn't Be a Pop hit: ✅Pop Song 89
Still has some of the Athens sound: ✅Get Up
Mike Mills Background Vocals taking the song from a 5 to a 7: ✅ You Are The Everything
The obligatory "Is this a good song?" Song that somehow made the record: ✅Stand
Pioneering Use of Sound/Instrumentation not previously found in Indie/Rock music at the time: ✅World Leader Pretend
Avant Garde R.E.M. brand weirdness: ✅ The Wrong Child
R.E.M Banger that goes to 11: ✅Orange Crush
Stipe taking a political stance with his lyrics: ✅ Turn You Inside Out
R.E.M Brand Tenderness/Love Song: ✅ Hairshirt
The Oddly Specific To Stipe's experience but Weirdly Universally Relatable Stipe Lyric:✅ I Remember California
Stipe Showing his Vocal Range: ✅ Untitled

Its not #1 in the cannon - but its averaging #10 on these lists - which is criminally low.
 
Last edited:
1. Monster
2. New Adventures in Hi-Fi
3. Document
3. Murmur
4. Automatic For The People
5. Out Of Time
6. Reckoning
7. Fables Of The Reconstruction
8. Dead Letter Offce
9. Green
10. Lifes Rich Pageant
11. Up
12. Reveal
13. Accelerate
14. Collapse Into Now
15. Around The Sun
 
King Crimson

01. In the Court of the Crimson King
02. Discipline
03. Red
04. Beat
05. Larks’ Tongues in Aspic
06. The Power to Believe
07. THRAK
08. Starless and Bible Black
09. Three of a Perfect Pair
10. Islands
11. In the Wake of Poseidon
12. Lizard
13. The Construkction of Light
 
avecigrec said:
King Crimson

01. In the Court of the Crimson King
02. Discipline
03. Red
04. Beat
05. Larks’ Tongues in Aspic
06. The Power to Believe
07. THRAK
08. Starless and Bible Black
09. Three of a Perfect Pair
10. Islands
11. In the Wake of Poseidon
12. Lizard
13. The Construkction of Light
Click to expand...
I’d put thrak and 3opp above power to believe but otherwise this is also my list.
 
avecigrec said:
I can get behind that.

If I were assigning my rankings letter grades, it would probably look something like this:

01-03 = A+
04-09 = A
10-12 = B
13-13 = C
Click to expand...
like my all-time favorite KC album is actually a playlist that I made of all my favorite songs which usually winds up being like 50-75% of a given album. I got into them -- like really really into them -- as a post-breakup therapy thing where I just decided "I'm going to learn how to do a hard thing" and I sat down and learned how to play a bunch of Crimson. So the 80s belew-era guitar fuckery is my jam but it's hard to pick any particular album and say it's bad. Like, even Lizard the worst thing about it is that it's basically "In the Court, Pt 2". Which isn't bad, but it's just kinda same-y in a way the other albums aren't.
 
Melt Face Molly Drop said:
Real Estate:

1. Atlas
2. Days
3. Daniel
4. In Mind
5. The Main Thing
6. Real Estate

2, 3 & 4 could realistically flip at any point.
Click to expand...
I loved their debut so this is complete wrong (but not really since if you put Real Estate at one everything else would be the same.)

Real Estate
Atlas
Days
Daniel
In Mind
The Main Thing

Also, I know he is a creep but I still prefer Matthew Mondanile’s guitar to Julian Lynch though there wasn’t a huge drop off.

I am also a big fan of Alex Bleeker’s and Martin Courtney’s respective solo albums too.
 
TenderLovingKiller® said:
I loved their debut so this is complete wrong (but not really since if you put Real Estate at one everything else would be the same.)

Real Estate
Atlas
Days
Daniel
In Mind
The Main Thing

Also, I know he is a creep but I still prefer Matthew Mondanile’s guitar to Julian Lynch though there wasn’t a huge drop off.

I am also a big fan of Alex Bleeker’s and Martin Courtney’s respective solo albums too.
Click to expand...
Agreed, I thought Mondanile's presence would be sorely missed but the band is so tight as is that I've mostly forgotten about their turnover (they also replaced their drummer on this last album).

I just listened to their debut and it's great, I just forgot how LoFi it was. Which, of course, is a positive, but you can feel that the band hadn't hit their stride just yet (didn't take long as it hit on Days).

I think I'll come around on The Main Thing, which largely is their most experimental to date, thus why I didn't put it last.
 
Melt Face Molly Drop said:
Agreed, I thought Mondanile's presence would be sorely missed but the band is so tight as is that I've mostly forgotten about their turnover (they also replaced their drummer on this last album).

I just listened to their debut and it's great, I just forgot how LoFi it was. Which, of course, is a positive, but you can feel that the band hadn't hit their stride just yet (didn't take long as it hit on Days).

I think I'll come around on The Main Thing, which largely is their most experimental to date, thus why I didn't put it last.
Click to expand...
You enjoy any of their solo stuff?
 
Real Estate:

  1. Atlas
  2. Days
  3. In Mind
  4. Real Estate
  5. Daniel
  6. The Main Thing

Daniel could overtake the s/t of which I'm not really too big of a fan. It's more rough and they hadn't really hit their stride yet. I really didn't like Real Estate until Days came out. In Mind is underrated IMO. It coincided with me seeing them live for the one and only time in 2017, so I just loved that album when it came out. There's some really catchy songs on that one but still a few duds.
 
wokeupnew said:
Real Estate:

  1. Atlas
  2. Days
  3. In Mind
  4. Real Estate
  5. Daniel
  6. The Main Thing

Daniel could overtake the s/t of which I'm not really too big of a fan. It's more rough and they hadn't really hit their stride yet. I really didn't like Real Estate until Days came out. In Mind is underrated IMO. It coincided with me seeing them live for the one and only time in 2017, so I just loved that album when it came out. There's some really catchy songs on that one but still a few duds.
Click to expand...
I wasn’t sold on In Mind really,TBH until I saw them perform a good chunk of it live. The live version helped me appreciate those songs in a different way.
 
throwingthings said:
i’d rank the “reality” EP above anything except “days”
Click to expand...
Yeah, I got really into that late 00s Lo-Fi scene on Woodist and Underwater Peoples; Pochahaunted, Ducktails, The Woods, Sad City, Family Portait, Andrew Cedarmark, Liam The Younger, Frat Dad, etc… So I really love those early Real Estate albums. I can understand why the Lo-Fi stuff isn’t everyone’s favorite though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top