Vinyl Me Please Essentials

Ginormousthumbs said:
This whole nickel theory reminds me of my awesome experience at one of my local record stores in town. Ironically this store also landed on VMPs Top 50 records stores in America thing. I had purchased a brand new copy of Oasis’ Definitely Maybe. Got it home and cracked the seal only to find that I had 2 copies of sides 3&4 and no side 1&2. Contacted the owner and he told me to come down for an exchange. We actually opened a couple of copies before we found one that had all 4 sides. While I was there I bought a new copy of The Lemonheads It’s A Shame About Ray. I love that album. Get it home and it’s got issues too. I message the owner and this is his response.....


View attachment 7534

Didn’t offer to exchange it or anything. Was very selective on what I bought from them moving forward. In fact it was pretty much limited to Record Store Day stuff until the stopped participating in that.
Click to expand...
Late to the game, but talking 11th Street there? I liked them for RSD 'cause it was much less traffic - Zia was crazy this year. Besides that, found their prices too high (I mean, at least they price their stuff unlike one Vegas store...). Found best customer service at Moondogs (will put an album on for your to hear, which is nice) and the Charleston Record City. Will say that candle lighting comment is golden...messed up, but golden.
 
TheMythOfSisyphus said:
Late to the game, but talking 11th Street there? I liked them for RSD 'cause it was much less traffic - Zia was crazy this year. Besides that, found their prices too high (I mean, at least they price their stuff unlike one Vegas store...). Found best customer service at Moondogs (will put an album on for your to hear, which is nice) and the Charleston Record City. Will say that candle lighting comment is golden...messed up, but golden.
Click to expand...

Yes to 11th Street. I really enjoyed shopping there in the beginning but dead stock and high prices just kept me away.
I didn’t participate in RSD this year but I like Zia’s new location on Rainbow.
Clint at Moondogs is always nice and most of the time willing to work with you. I think he is great at updating his inventory and it’s usually in great shape. I just don’t shop there enough.
Have only been to Wax Trax once and that was enough. If I lived closer to Record City Charleston I’d probably shop there a lot. Joey is great and there’s always interesting conversations that arise. Honestly I don’t shop enough locally. Sometimes I feel bad but I’d just rather order directly from the artist or label. And most of the things that are on my want list I know I’m not going to find them locally so then Discogs comes in to play.
 
goodoohuru said:
I don't know if its just a coincidence that I haven't really liked any of the VMP releases since our nuking or that its always been like that and the VMP Forum was a pair of virtual rose coloured glasses.
Click to expand...
Jmcg85 said:
I always felt like they were the masters at creating FOMO, I definitely bought less before I joined forum, kept buying needlessly when involved in their forum, since that forum has gone things have calmed down again quiet a bit and I feel much better for it now
Click to expand...
Selaws said:
I've still been keeping an eye on the store as I have credits to use. However, its amazing how little interest I have had in their picks that I have never heard of before. It used to be that I would jump to the forum and read the reviews/hype from you guys and no doubt end up putting an order in blind based purely on that alone. This was really the ultimate club experience as my tastes were expanded as a result. Now I dont even bother with the members store, if I go in blind on something it will be a pick up from my local shop after seeing something pop up on the pre-order/fresh grabs/no spinning etc. Everyone's a winner......except those that shall not be named.
Click to expand...
so, I know we all know this ish to be self-evident- it was speculated on the old forum, shouted during it's implosion, and mostly confirmed in our new home. but out of curiosity, I finally did an autopsy on my VMP history since joining the "club," and thought I'd drop the main takeaways from my personal #s for those interested. this does include subscription records.

without-forum average (before & after): $28.22 a month, 1.21 records a month
with-forum average: $181.00 a month, 8.3 records a month

the average cost of a record has definitely increased. my personal numbers for 2016-2018 stayed pretty consistent, although most of my large purchases did come during their sales. way less purchases and higher costs this year finally spiked the average by $3 a record.

*note- I cancelled my recently-renewed annual membership as the old place went crashing, but I did not ask for a refund of the remaining months, so the without-forum numbers include the coming months averaged out. it does not account for any future purchases, but at my rate in 2019, I don't foresee many of those. I also had more discretionary funds before this year, but my purchasing volume pre-VMP forum was still lower.

this concludes my TED talk, thanks!
 
bfly said:
so, I know we all know this ish to be self-evident- it was speculated on the old forum, shouted during it's implosion, and mostly confirmed in our new home. but out of curiosity, I finally did an autopsy on my VMP history since joining the "club," and thought I'd drop the main takeaways from my personal #s for those interested. this does include subscription records.

without-forum average (before & after): $28.22 a month, 1.21 records a month
with-forum average: $181.00 a month, 8.3 records a month

the average cost of a record has definitely increased. my personal numbers for 2016-2018 stayed pretty consistent, although most of my large purchases did come during their sales. way less purchases and higher costs this year finally spiked the average by $3 a record.

*note- I cancelled my recently-renewed annual membership as the old place went crashing, but I did not ask for a refund of the remaining months, so the without-forum numbers include the coming months averaged out. it does not account for any future purchases, but at my rate in 2019, I don't foresee many of those. I also had more discretionary funds before this year, but my purchasing volume pre-VMP forum was still lower.

this concludes my TED talk, thanks!
Click to expand...
Woah! I knew it was bad but this is crazy. Postman hasn't been coming at all. I've really been more lowkey since the forum shut. Good looking out on the math and facts
 
bfly said:
so, I know we all know this ish to be self-evident- it was speculated on the old forum, shouted during it's implosion, and mostly confirmed in our new home. but out of curiosity, I finally did an autopsy on my VMP history since joining the "club," and thought I'd drop the main takeaways from my personal #s for those interested. this does include subscription records.

without-forum average (before & after): $28.22 a month, 1.21 records a month
with-forum average: $181.00 a month, 8.3 records a month

the average cost of a record has definitely increased. my personal numbers for 2016-2018 stayed pretty consistent, although most of my large purchases did come during their sales. way less purchases and higher costs this year finally spiked the average by $3 a record.

*note- I cancelled my recently-renewed annual membership as the old place went crashing, but I did not ask for a refund of the remaining months, so the without-forum numbers include the coming months averaged out. it does not account for any future purchases, but at my rate in 2019, I don't foresee many of those. I also had more discretionary funds before this year, but my purchasing volume pre-VMP forum was still lower.

this concludes my TED talk, thanks!
Click to expand...
If I was more ambitious, I'd try to figure out my time spent on the store site before forum shut down, and since.
I had been slowing down on store time anyway, but since the forum shut down I barely even log into the store or browse it.

Having said that, VMP regularly reminded us that the forum is a very small percentage of members. I honestly think they gladly traded forum member ad-ons for more monthly single sub sign-ups. Recurring revenue to keep the books in line and few items to manage. We're just the data for VMP's "share holder" and "accounting" clubs now.

It all makes since when you look at it from a business school prospective. I feel more and more that they are trying to cash in as much as they can before the vinyl train starts to slow down.
 
I saw an OG pressing of “Uno, Dos, Tres” at the local record store for $19. If the jacket was in a bit better shape I probably would went that route but I am going to (probably wrongly) hold out hope that VMP can get my a nice copy in better condition for a few bucks more. We’ll see what happens.
 
GelloJive said:
VMP is just way less interesting now. Barely any chatter on these records compared to previous months. Kinda sad actually but looking at it as an opportunity to expand my horizons.
Click to expand...

Yep, getting rid of the forums means I don't visit the site very often, and less likely to order anything extra. Add in some less than inspiring monthly picks and dwindling swap options and my time is numbered , just need them to ship funkadelic (delayed yet again) and I think I’m out
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top