So I emailed in directly to info@ demanding to know where my missing orders were, and the response I finally got was not a great one:
_______________________
Hey Steve,
I'm so so sorry but those items were unfortunately oversold so I'll have to cancel and refund that. I sincerely apologize for the inconvenience. A more detailed explanation will go out to effected customers on Friday.
Tyler
Customer Support Agent
Vinyl Me, Please
_______________________
So, to summarize, one of these albums, Blossom Dearie, I specifically chatted in to ensure was really in stock and was EMPHATICALLY assured that it was and would ship to me by CS. The other was Jay Som, which I purchased on Black Friday and until VERY recently was still in stock. Hell, they had a chance to mark it down since I ordered at full price (with a discount code, but still). So, I call horse shit all around here and it pains me to suspect that any of you still waiting on stuff may be in for a similar experience. I truly hope not, but it seems as though they massively oversold some stuff during their enormous clusterfuck of a website transition, had no idea what order to send anything out, and now many of us will just get a "OOPS SORRY" email.
They at least claim to have refunded me, but I will watching PayPal like a hawk to ensure they actually do. Oh, and the $30 in credit I used on one of those orders is just gone now apparently. What a shit show.