Vinyl Me Please (store, exclusives, swaps, etc)

Got a dings and dents 12 pack in the UK, not sure how many of these I'd have paid $15 for in a fire sale, but equally doesn't feel like a complete disaster... and probably the best way to extract any kind of value from my remaining store credits...

Black Sabbath - Paranoia
The National - Boxer
Buck Owens - Carnegie Hall
Sigur Ros - Agaetis Byrjun
Doug Sahm - Groovers Paradise
Labelle - Nightbirds
CNN - The War Report
Japandroids - Celebration Rock
Dave Van Ronk - Folksinger
Lyle Lovett - Joshua Judges Ruth
Sylvester - Step II
Mar Keys/Booker T - Back to Back
Sabbath is a very nice get assuming it’s the VMP x Kevin gray cut
 
Is it safe to say that the Cameron/Plant fiasco did them in or do you all think they were toast before all that happened?
supposedly, VMP almost hit bankruptcy earlier and was saved. I believe there was info in it from the wrongful termination countersuit by one of the guys in the c-suite.

the plant stuff really fucked them though. outside financing fell through, causing them to do all those 40% off sales which severly diluted the brand value. plus that freebies sign up also devalued them. i also think they did an awful job at forecasting sales and overpressed nearly everything plus did represses that way too big and are still in stock.
 
imo, their model was already becoming unsustainable due to price/access to titles and losing all that money to some light fraud just sped up their eventual demise
supposedly, VMP almost hit bankruptcy earlier and was saved. I believe there was info in it from the wrongful termination countersuit by one of the guys in the c-suite.

the plant stuff really fucked them though. outside financing fell through, causing them to do all those 40% off sales which severly diluted the brand value. plus that freebies sign up also devalued them. i also think they did an awful job at forecasting sales and overpressed nearly everything plus did represses that way too big and are still in stock.

So do we think they fold pretty quickly or do you think they are looking for a buyer? They seem to be just basically existing at this point.
 
Last edited:
So do we think they fold pretty quickly or do you think they are looking for a buyer? They seem to be just basically existing at this point.
I’m pretty surprised they’ve hung on this long. The company is basically just Matt plus one these days? Right?

Someone may buy the brand as a repressing label but I think their goose is cooked as a single company.
 
I assume they're looking for a buyer, otherwise they would have folded already. Explains why they're still shipping in stock items/doing sales/giving away things for free to victims of the fire. Getting rid of inventory so a potential buyer isn't burdened with it.

imo, their model was already becoming unsustainable due to price/access to titles and losing all that money to some light fraud just sped up their eventual demise
I think this is true in terms of the size that had grown to. However, I think that speaks to a larger issue, which is trying to bring a tech/Fortune 500 company mentality to a business model that requires a lot of inventory and ultimately has a limited ceiling in customer growth (plus actually has the detrimental effect of potentially alienating your initial customer base by having to branch in areas they have no interest in).

Essentially, you're stuck with a business that requires a lot of inventory across a lot of skews in order to grow. And even then, at some point you're going to hit a ceiling.

Furthermore, bringing a subscription model to a product that has a permanent physical ownership to it means you're always going to experience a lot of churn, because you're dealing with the realities of people's space, and there is nothing to offer them with the subscription outside of 'what is next'. In comparison to Spotify, where you lose access to all the music, no one at VMP is coming to collect all the records you own the moment you unsubscribe.
 
If they’re looking for a buyer they are dumb. Ain’t no one gonna buy their name, no one is gonna get any use out of their customer list because they might as well have burned that which was literally all they owned.

They’re going to sell things as long as possible to fend off debts.

I’m not gonna get into the need for inventory, that was a self inflicted wound by making swaps an unsustainable model.

Prior to the big tech boom, all subscriptions were for physical media. Columbia house was so big that they could deal with thousands of people ripping them off every year with out flinching.

The nail that did their coffin in was when they became beheld to venture capital because they thought they needed unbridled growth because that is what America’s particular version of evil capitalism demands.

Big labels wanting to run their own subscriptions or audiophile sublabels as well as actually being a niche luxery product always meant they had a shelf life. Piss poor customer interaction that led to them pissing off their most fervent base no less than three times along with piss poor quality control and piss poor management - inventory control, fuck sales - what really devalued their brand was the constant need to bend to the new customer while making promises to their base they would never meet, over listening to customers creating a basic choose your own model which played havoc with their curated for you model, and whatever actually happened with the plant just pushed the end closer to now than later.
 
imo, their model was already becoming unsustainable due to price/access to titles and losing all that money to some light fraud just sped up their eventual demise
This article covers many of the issues faced by a business like VMP before you even have an issue like the pressing plant:
Think about VMP's multiple tracks and sub/pay options, people changing plans, doing business internationally, etc as you read this and you get a sense of how scaling their business so quickly was difficult.
 
This article covers many of the issues faced by a business like VMP before you even have an issue like the pressing plant:
Think about VMP's multiple tracks and sub/pay options, people changing plans, doing business internationally, etc as you read this and you get a sense of how scaling their business so quickly was difficult.

There's basically only 2 successful models for subscription services:

1) You blow up an entire sector and become a market leader in the space, crippling legacy companies in your wake. This takes a lot of capital to do, and your product has to end up being viewed as utility by subscribers (Netflix/Spotify etc.)

2) You offer a very niche product with a committed customer base, with a bunch of upsells for those members on a monthly basis. You have a stable customer base that stays relatively stagnant. This was VMPs initial offering. However, it still only really maintains itself if the customer loses something by unsubscribing, and so still best for tech products.

IMO, VMPs issue was they were desperately trying to get to 1 without figuring a way to address the fundamental flaw in their model. Their best move likely would have been drop the subscription service sooner (or let it become less of focus) and just become a boutique label a la Numero Group, Light in the Attic etc. They would have likely had to narrow their focus in doing so, but could have been a successful, albeit small business.
 
Back
Top