I'm not a big horror movie fan, but I AM a huge Simpsons fan, and love their Halloween specials. Even while the show has had an observable decline in quality, the Halloween episodes are always fun. I decided to try and watch all of them before Halloween and thought I'd share them here. So here we go!
Treehouse of Horror I -
Segments: Bad Dream House, Hungry are the Damned, The Raven
For me, The Raven makes this one, but having James Earl Jones as a guest voice throughout makes this a classic. His work on the Raven though is just one of those things that can live on in eternity in my mind.
Treehouse of Horror II -
Segments: Lisa's Nightmare (The Monkey's Paw), Bart's Nightmare (It's a Good Life), Homer's Nightmare (Frankenstein)
This one is solid. The unsettling nature of Bart's Nightmare is essentially a seven minute joke with a fantastic payoff. The one liners start to come out in the writing here, and looking back you can see that the third season is where the Simpsons started to find their stride
Treehouse of Horror III -
Segments: Clown Without Pity, King Homer, Dial 'Z' for Zombies
Seeing that Krusty Doll with sharp teeth always gives me a shivers. I like this one a lot because the writing is just so sharp. King Homer is the perfect parody in my mind and Dial 'Z' always makes me laugh.
Treehouse of Horror IV -
Segments: The Devil and Homer Simpson, Terror at 5 1/2 Feet, Bart Simpson's Dracula
Again, really really good episode here, from start to finish.
The Night Gallery as a wraparound is so good. I have a soft spot for any of the episodes that Conan wrote, and you can easily hear his voice doing Bart's part of that so well. There is a timelessness element of this one, and this is where the Simpsons were constantly good if not great. There were several parts where I am audibly laughing out loud, I just really love this one. Flanders as the Devil is still hilarious to me and you can't not love Lionel Hutz.
Treehouse of Horror V -
Segments: The Shinning, Time and Punishment, Nightmare Cafeteria
This is the granddaddy of them all for me. The Shinning alone is one of the best things the Simpsons have ever done, neatly splicing together horror, satire, and commentary of the 90s. Time and Punishment could be a full episode if they wanted it to be, it's just so entertaining to see Homer change the past and then see his future. There are other moments of brilliance here I love: the increase in violence here in response to complaints that The Simpsons was too violent, the running gag of Willie getting an ax in the back, and Maggie being voiced by James Earl Jones(!) all make this one not just the best Treehouse of Horror episode, but one of the best episodes of The Simpsons period.
Treehouse of Horror VI -
Segments: Attack of the 50 Foot Eyesores, Nightmare on Evergreen Terrace, Homer3
I came really close to giving this one 3
but there are a few things I like a lot that bumped it back to 4. Nightmare on Evergreen Terrace has some great parts, like lousy Smarch weather, Martin's dream, and Maggie saving the day. Homer3 is boundary pushing and revolutionary, but as an episode it's a little weak (although the writing is actually pretty good). And the end of Eyesores is great.
Next installment coming soon!