I started doing AOTYs in 2012 (note I was 16 when I started this lol)
2012: Imagine Dragons - Night Visions
2013: Twenty One Pilots - Vessel
2014: Lana Del Rey - Ultraviolence
2015: Father John Misty - I Love You Honeybear
2016: Beyoncé - Lemonade
2017: St Vincent - MASSeduction
2018: U.S. Girls - In a Poem Unlimited
2019: Lana Del Rey - Norman Fucking Rockwell
2020: Jessie Ware - What’s Your Pleasure?
2021: St Vincent - Daddy’s Home
2022: Beyoncé - RENAISSANCE
Worth noting that in that short time I’ve already have 3 winners who’ve won twice
The earliest I can remember making a list was in 2009
If I wanted to reevaluate these lists I’d probably include other albums that I didn’t even know about at the time. But, that defeats the point of the lists. Source:
neckermanncj's journal | Last.fm
2009: The Pains of Being Pure at Heart - s/t
2010: The National - High Violet
2011: Dustin O’Halloran - Lumiere
2012: The Mountain Goats - Transcendental Youth
2013: Eluvium - Nightmare Ending
2014: Nothing - Guilty of Everything
2015: Sufjan Stevens - Carrie & Lowell
2016: Eluvium - False Readings On
2017: Julie Byrne - Not Even Happiness
2018: Wild Nothing - Indigo
2019: The National - I Am Easy To Find
2020: Yumi Zouma - Truth or Consequences
2021: Men I Trust - Untourable Album