MikeH
Well-Known Member
The AS stuff on discogs is mostly returns or some warehouse finds it seems. They posted quite a lot of albums with a slight seam split with NM vinyl. The AP Waltz for Debby I got is exactly that. The Cisco American Woman I got is because Cisco had some issues with weird discoloration on some vinyl that DNAP at all. It sounds awesome. Keep in mind--AS's discogs items are actually properly graded from what I've experienced--even on the side of conservative, plus they are cleaned and sent in nice inners and behind the sleeve in an outer. I have paid less on the few i bought than they have been listed anywhere else. I get that it's shady sometimes (especially when it's an AS pressed item that's on backorder or available on their site new for less...) but I just avoid those.I'm not sure if it is shadiness, or more a case of buyer beware and get informed before buying. Big box online retailers like AS and MD have warehouses full of deadstock from returns, and no outlets to shift them out and recoup on the wholesale cost. They have to go somewhere. I would think it fairly rare that they would simply trash a return.
There is no way they would be able to catalog and individually identify the specific defects on every one of (at least) hundreds or thousands of returns. Some, probably a fair proportion, may have no defects at all - just sent back by some asshole with a shitty or badly calibrated setup, or some visual defect that an obsessive type trumped up into something major, or a bent corner. l bet a record someone returns claiming pops and clicks on their Crossley may well be flawless on a decent setup. You take your chances - that's why they are discounted.
Amazon does this too - those 'warehouse deals'. Buyer beware. They are cheaper for a reason, or often, several reasons.
Personally, I would not save a few bucks to end up with someone else's problem, or take my chances rolling the dice on getting lucky that it was a return without justification and not strike out.
The Hobson stuff was a shitshow though...