Definitive Audiophile pressings

Does anyone have either the ROG extended version of Dr. John's The Sun, Moon and Herbs or the Speakers Corner version they could comment on? I'm trying to decide which one to use a coupon on and while I'm tempted by the extras it's hard to go wrong with SC.
 
Hemotep said:
Does anyone have either the ROG extended version of Dr. John's The Sun, Moon and Herbs or the Speakers Corner version they could comment on? I'm trying to decide which one to use a coupon on and while I'm tempted by the extras it's hard to go wrong with SC.
Click to expand...
ROG is no slouch in general. If you want the extras I bet you’d be happy with the ROG. I’ve yet to be disappointed by their pressings. Don’t know this specific comparison though since I don’t have either!
 
Mather said:
I haven't heard the Sax, just heard about it. But I find the BG very muffled and overly soft. I've had the BG Wall, DSOTM and WYWH and overall I thought the Wall fared best in terms of stacking up to earlier presses. It's punchy as all get out, but still too soft and lacking detail for me compared to earlier presses. That's why I grabbed the JP first press of that one
Click to expand...
The BG is digital, the Sax is analog. That's the cause!
 
RHANDMJ said:
The BG is digital, the Sax is analog. That's the cause!
Click to expand...
The 2011 Sax is from a hi-res transfer. Not analog. (For what it’s worth, so is the 2016 BG.)

Which "Wish You Were Here" Do You Want?

It's a bit late in the day to write a review of the music on this album, which concerns itself with how the music business chews up musicians with dreams and spits them out—not that Syd Barrett, the subject of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" was done in by the business. So how does this reissue...
www.analogplanet.com www.analogplanet.com
 
markmck79 said:
The 2011 Sax is from a hi-res transfer. Not analog. (For what it’s worth, so is the 2016 BG.)

Which "Wish You Were Here" Do You Want?

It's a bit late in the day to write a review of the music on this album, which concerns itself with how the music business chews up musicians with dreams and spits them out—not that Syd Barrett, the subject of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" was done in by the business. So how does this reissue...
www.analogplanet.com www.analogplanet.com
Click to expand...
I say go for a Barry cut (1981).

I just grabbed the JP 1st press cause it was $50 and mint. I'll never get the chance on that again.

Barry cut is on my bucket list.
 
It's good but not crazy money good, unless you just want to collect it.
If I were to improve anything on it, probably vocals. Overall, it's a solid play and very quite.

My US Wall pressing is the goldilocks for mastering on a PF album so far. It's a TML stamp.
 
Mather said:
The Tidal streams are very muffled, I suspect they're some version of the 2016 mix. With added Tidal bass... which seems to be a thing Tidal does with their EQing...
Click to expand...
I could see a noticeable improvement switching from Tidal to Qobuz. Most people with good DACs will.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top