In an absolute buzzer beater of a finish, I completed Final Fantasy XIII last night at around 11:30, for the last day being on Game Pass. I feel like I've got way to much to say on this one, but I'll try not to ramble too much.
Overall, I really enjoyed this game. I have some issues that I will get to, but for the most part I had a positive experience playing this game. I shied away from this one initially due to what seemed like an overwhelmingly negative reception at the time. I now think that a lot of the haters only played for a few chapters.
That's as good a transition as any to get to the negatives. First off, this game is confusing as hell for way longer than it should be. I don't think I really started to get a grasp on anything until at least Chapter 8 (there's 13 total). Combat is way different from anything else I've played. There are 6 different roles any character can take on, and you choose combinations of roles between 3 characters into paradigms, that you can switch between on the fly. I feel like this isn't explained all that well, and took a lot of practice and online walkthroughs to start feeling comfortable. The story also starts off very confusing, with all the l'cie, fal'Cie, pulse fal'Cie, etc. mentions coming at you a mile a minute, as if you know what any of that means. Figuring out how to pronounce those is tricky enough (I played with Japanese audio), but understanding the differences takes some deep reading of the Codex entries. Another issue I had was with the camera, this thing fights you trying to control it constantly, even in the more open areas. There's a lot of hallways, especially earlier on, but even in the wide open areas it can be a struggle to look around you. Finally, some of the random game overs get frustrating. A single group of enemies can range from the easiest thing you've ever encountered, to "hey, lets all attack the primary character at the same time with no telegraphing and wipe their health instantly. Seriously, I struggled more with the enemies on the way through the final chapter than I did with any of the bosses. One final nitpick, a better fast travel would be amazing here - like being able to travel between save points.
Nailing these transitions, let's move on to the positives. First off, the bosses. I feel like most of these were well designed and fair. They also did that classic FF thing where they utilize the different mechanics to get you out of your comfort zone and trying new strategies. I'm sure some people dislike the very linear nature to most of the game, but I didn't mind it. The others in the series are often the same situation, but get less flack for it. In this case, it gives you plenty of time to admire the stunning graphics. This game still looks incredible, even though it's almost 13 years old. The cutscenes are some of the best in the series that I've seen, and had some very hype moments. I like that you can see the enemies on the map, and can time things to get a preemptive strike. I mentioned combat was confusing earlier, but once you get the hang of it, things are very engaging. Seldom did I find myself just pressing A to get through a fight. The paradigm shifting is a cool concept. The stagger system, in which you build up combos to stagger an enemy, exposing weakness and allowing extra damage, is utilized well. I also really like the characters and story. Everyone involved either had very clear motives for being there and fighting how they did, or found those motives along the way. Some of the stuff at the end is a bit confusing, but the ending itself is great and left me ready to play the next one.
I know I wrote more on the negatives, but the things I liked far outweighed what I didn't. While not as impactful on me personally as 6, 7, 9, and 10, I like this one way more than 8, which I replayed last year. I'd say it's on par with 15, and it's been too long since I played the others to have a good opinion currently. For reference, I loved 8 as a kid, but as an adult I see every glaring issue, while the others in time frame all hold up really well. Looking forward to jumping right into XIII-2!