I’m team Kid Amnesiac.
We all acknowledge, though, that Kid A and Amnesiac are actually two halves of one single album, though, right? Two puzzle pieces meant to be spliced together.
Think about it. Two albums recorded in the same sessions, both with eleven tracks. You start with “Everything in It’s Right Place” which is Thom’s version of an inside joke, because the tracks are all actually spread out across two albums - haha, what a jokester. Then you go over to “Packd Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box” which is basically a continuation of the sentence started by EIIRP and also the punchline to that joke. You just keep alternating between the two albums track by track until you get to the part where the cacophony of horns in National Anthem resurface in Life in a Glass House and closes it all out. This is a Jekyll and Hyde situation. I mean, listen to the swirling harp sounds at the end of Motion Picture Soundtrack and the swirling glitchy sounds at the beginning of Like Spinning Plates and tell me there’s no connection there.
Give us the 4LP version of Kid Amnesiac we’ve been waiting for! Where Pyramid Song leads into National Anthem which leads into Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors. The natural progression from I might be wrong into Optimistic. Where Morning Bell is actually the reprise of “Morning Bell/Amensiac”.
The truth is out there.