Hemotep
Well-Known Member
Watched Nope tonight and absolutely loved it until about the last five minutes, which I felt were uninspired and unworthy of the excellent ode to classic sci-fi film that Peele created.
If it weren't for that it would be my favorite of his films because I love this take on the genre, not because it's his best, because from a plot standpoint and overall acting standpoint it's objectively not. But from a cinematography and audio standpoint he's grown in great ways. It borrowed shots from landscape films, paid homage to scenes from classic films, and he doesn't overdo it on the special effects, using them only enough to be effective in setting the mood. But he sacrificed some character and relationship development, and if we follow Tobias Wolfe's ideas for stories, he doesn't do enough to establish the links in the chain that exist before and after the story in the viewer's mind. And this is necessary so that we can keep telling the story in our own minds once what is given to us is done. It's what gives a story life beyond what the author provides. But Nope starts and it ends, and it could have been more for the viewer without it being more for the film with a few different choices or additions in the dialog.
Despite these flaws, he's one of the most original and exciting filmmakers today. He takes risks and is creating a lineage of films that are worthy of study by aspiring film makers. I could easily design a course on his work so far, and I'm sure it will only get richer as he continues to create.
If it weren't for that it would be my favorite of his films because I love this take on the genre, not because it's his best, because from a plot standpoint and overall acting standpoint it's objectively not. But from a cinematography and audio standpoint he's grown in great ways. It borrowed shots from landscape films, paid homage to scenes from classic films, and he doesn't overdo it on the special effects, using them only enough to be effective in setting the mood. But he sacrificed some character and relationship development, and if we follow Tobias Wolfe's ideas for stories, he doesn't do enough to establish the links in the chain that exist before and after the story in the viewer's mind. And this is necessary so that we can keep telling the story in our own minds once what is given to us is done. It's what gives a story life beyond what the author provides. But Nope starts and it ends, and it could have been more for the viewer without it being more for the film with a few different choices or additions in the dialog.
Despite these flaws, he's one of the most original and exciting filmmakers today. He takes risks and is creating a lineage of films that are worthy of study by aspiring film makers. I could easily design a course on his work so far, and I'm sure it will only get richer as he continues to create.