I gave it another listen this morning via Spotify and it's not clicking for me. It's inexpensive and she's Italian, so this should be something I grab, but - for me - it hasn't clicked. The album starts off sounding almost like it could be music from The Commitments which I dig, but then it drifts back into the Atlantic sound sorta like Dusty Springfield's Dusty in Memphis. I've got the Dusty album, because I love the sound of Son of A Preacher Man, but then the rest of the album is nothing like that song. Sorta the same thing with Nicole when comparing the first half of the album to the second half. It ends up sounding - to me - more like a greatest hits album than a cohesive studio album.
I've still got the album saved on Spotify as I'm going to give another listen in short order to try to convince myself I'm wrong. I just don't want to bring in a piece of vinyl that I don't spin.