I reached out to Nick so I'm curious to see what he suggests. The pad is a little sticky to the touch, like when I press my hand on it and lift up it sticks to my hand for a bit before falling off, so I'm thinking that's why? It's kind of sticking to the record? It left the marks before I even started cleaning it. I just put the record on there to make sure I knew how to set everything up and noticed it right away.
I appreciate both of providing your feedback, thanks! I'll try not pressing down so hard and see what Nick suggests. I may try to clean the pad too since he says in the video it can be washed. I'll report back when I figure things out.