So, I had something a little more similar to a paint edger, and that worked a hundred times better. I guess I feel misled, perhaps due to lack of research, that the Vinyl Zyme fell under the "let the fluid do the work" category in this following paragraph I found on an RCM review. The record I was trying to play was new but bought used, so not a dollar binner under any circumstances but was rather noisy:
People generally fall into two camps regarding cleaning methodology as well. The "scrubbers" who think that scrubbing all the dirt out of the record is the most important, and the "let the fluid do the work" people. My opinion on this leans more towards the latter, but then again I am not a hardcore thrift store or dollar bin record digger. Most of the records I buy are either new records or VG+ records that are just a bit dusty with some fingerprints. Extremely dirty or mold-damaged records should probably be pre-cleaned before being run through an RCM.