Vinyl Me Please Anthology

Price is way too high for me, but I do think it’s decently fair. The issue is very small runs (1000 each) and high demand content (is high licensing fees). To my personal tatstes this release checks all the right boxes with quality and citation, but 8 albums at this high rate just pushes it past my price bracket. Obviously not everything is as much of a steal as the Dylan box at $17.50 per LP, but with deals like that out there it makes this a hard choice for me to make. But if you have the do-re-mi, and can deal with VMPs BS, this will probably be the best these records will ever sound on vinyl. Those tapes aren’t getting any younger.
 
Price is way too high for me, but I do think it’s decently fair. The issue is very small runs (1000 each) and high demand content (is high licensing fees). To my personal tatstes this release checks all the right boxes with quality and citation, but 8 albums at this high rate just pushes it past my price bracket. Obviously not everything is as much of a steal as the Dylan box at $17.50 per LP, but with deals like that out there it makes this a hard choice for me to make. But if you have the do-re-mi, and can deal with VMPs BS, this will probably be the best these records will ever sound on vinyl. Those tapes aren’t getting any younger.
TBH, I could have lived with $25-30 per LP, which would have been spot on for what I anticipate them presenting. I just don’t see the $345/295 price point being remotely reasonable.
 
Yeah I'm not super savvy and I just clicked around until I came across it. $295 is the "early bird discount" price.

After the BN Anthology discount, $265 for 8 albums comes to just over $33 an album. Based on other comments, this is high for Motown records, but if you compare this with their standard store pricing, it's not that surprising that the price is $265. The set was a lock for me at like $230 or lower, but I'm gonna have to really think about it.

Knowing myself, I'll probably cave to the hype tomorrow when it's selling like crazy, but it's gonna hurt the wallet.

lol honestly wasn't that well hidden!

Very cool! I have also been trying to sell some records to free up cash for the Blue Note Review vol. 3 (whenever it is announced), The Schiit Sol, and <sigh> probably the VMP Anthology 2.

I'm really tempted by the BN review but I need more music... two records and a comp didn't entice me enough. Even though the extras look really cool and the albums do look good... (talking myself into it).
 
lol honestly wasn't that well hidden!



I'm really tempted by the BN review but I need more music... two records and a comp didn't entice me enough. Even though the extras look really cool and the albums do look good... (talking myself into it).

The extras are really well-done, even though I wasn't really interested in any of them. The quality of the cards is top-notch, and the record brush is... well, it's a record brush! The zines were actually pretty cool, and the box itself and the jacket for the comp are works of art. I'd have been just as happy paying $150 and getting just the records.
 
Still a few hours before the sale, but ...


tl;dr - everything is shipped together this time

Digging into some XML from those Shopify pages, it's apparently going to be 345 and 295 with the "early bird" discount (+40 for intl shipping, as said in the FAQ)
 
Still a few hours before the sale, but ...


tl;dr - everything is shipped together this time

Digging into some XML from those Shopify pages, it's apparently going to be 345 and 295 with the "early bird" discount (+40 for intl shipping, as said in the FAQ)
I don’t get it, if they’re all shipped together, why aren’t they all revealed at presale?

Like, it feels like the concept has shifted from “limited run subscription following a specific concept” to “surprise bundle.” I mean, if I were to walk into a store that was selling a black box priced at $345 with nothing but a sticker outside of it that said “Women of Motown”, there’s no way in hell I’d buy that without knowing what’s in it. I’d probably really like it, but I DON’T like surprises that cost $345.
 
Still a few hours before the sale, but ...


tl;dr - everything is shipped together this time

Digging into some XML from those Shopify pages, it's apparently going to be 345 and 295 with the "early bird" discount (+40 for intl shipping, as said in the FAQ)

Well I'm definitely disappointed they're shipping all at once. That was a big part of why I liked the first antho...
 
I don’t get it, if they’re all shipped together, why aren’t they all revealed at presale?

Like, it feels like the concept has shifted from “limited run subscription following a specific concept” to “surprise bundle.” I mean, if I were to walk into a store that was selling a black box priced at $345 with nothing but a sticker outside of it that said “Women of Motown”, there’s no way in hell I’d buy that without knowing what’s in it. I’d probably really like it, but I DON’T like surprises that cost $345.

Well I'm definitely disappointed they're shipping all at once. That was a big part of why I liked the first antho...

Looks like they're still trying to find the best approach here. Everything is shipped together, but in "secrecy sleeves", so it's up to the buyer to decide when they want to find out what's in the box.

The cost for international shipping is a bummer as well, considering that there might be additional customs / courier fees, that could hurt badly on a 300$ package... Still undecided with so much uncertainty on the 8 records, but wondering if I should ship to the US and use something like addresspal.anpost.ie to save a few €.

Edit: Thanks @Jan for clarifying - custom fees are prepaid as part of the international shipping costs, so that's actually a fair deal (compared to getting 20% VAT + customs / courier fees)
 
Last edited:
TBH, I could have lived with $25-30 per LP, which would have been spot on for what I anticipate them presenting. I just don’t see the $345/295 price point being remotely reasonable.

For sure, the price sucks, but that’s why you don’t see any audiophile companies doing HUGE titles at a run of 1000. I remember Storf claimed at the old forum that if they made the Fist City exclusive (also a run of 1000) a AAA cut it would have driven the cost up to $45 for them to make a profit. That’s not to far off what we see here. Think the issue is they’re cramming so much into this box (also account for the time they spend designing snd marketing this to a very high standard) and ordering so little of it that the economy of scale doesn’t work in their favor. They have to make a profit off of what is essentially 8 high quality releases while sticking to the super small run that so many people go bananas for, stoking that FOMO.

One other note is that the labels own mono box is a super high price point as well, so who knows how much Motown wants to squeeze this lemon. They’re also entering an audiophile market that’s become increasingly loony, with the ridiculous standards set by the One-Steps and UHQRs pretty much redefining the ceiling of sanity. As much as the audiophile crowd likes to look down our nose at the amount people charge for lame-ass colored pressings these days, I think we like to ignore that we’re really in a golden age for boutique BS. IMO this is a high ticket item, and not a trend I like to see, but still feels more tolerable than paying $125 for one 2X45RPM release.
 
The cost for international shipping is a bummer as well, considering that there might be additional customs / courier fees,
The intl shipping of 40$ is fair, as the faq claims that customs is paid out of that upfront.
The whole package is just too much for albums i don't care deeply enough about to spensd that money.
Plus i'm more and more souring to marketung that is just about raising fomo, giving as little information possible to nudge us into making ad-hoc desciosions under the pressure of quick sell-outs. If that works for this set they are obviously doing the right thing from a business perspective. It's just not for someone like me anymore.
Another thing is, i was sad at first because i literally slept when tge bn anthoöogy went on sale and i missed it. But it was a good thing in the end. For me as someone still relatively new to jazz, there was nothing in the box that i desperately needed. the bn80 and tone poets are enough to scraatch that itch for me. And i could read about and listen to the releases up front to pick up the ones according to my taste.
 
For sure, the price sucks, but that’s why you don’t see any audiophile companies doing HUGE titles at a run of 1000. I remember Storf claimed at the old forum that if they made the Fist City exclusive (also a run of 1000) a AAA cut it would have driven the cost up to $45 for them to make a profit. That’s not to far off what we see here. Think the issue is they’re cramming so much into this box (also account for the time they spend designing snd marketing this to a very high standard) and ordering so little of it that the economy of scale doesn’t work in their favor. They have to make a profit off of what is essentially 8 high quality releases while sticking to the super small run that so many people go bananas for, stoking that FOMO.

One other note is that the labels own mono box is a super high price point as well, so who knows how much Motown wants to squeeze this lemon. They’re also entering an audiophile market that’s become increasingly loony, with the ridiculous standards set by the One-Steps and UHQRs pretty much redefining the ceiling of sanity. As much as the audiophile crowd likes to look down our nose at the amount people charge for lame-ass colored pressings these days, I think we like to ignore that we’re really in a golden age for boutique BS. IMO this is a high ticket item, and not a trend I like to see, but still feels more tolerable than paying $125 for one 2X45RPM release.

If we have 8 (well, 9...) AAA LPs with hi-quality pressing and sleeves, the price point of the box itself (w/ discount) is not so unreasonable I'd say. I recently picked some Tone Poet releases for 35€ each (around 38$ - and FWIW they're among the best sounding record I have) so that's in-line with the box-set price (not discussing the Blue Note audiophile vs Motown thing here).
 
Last edited:
Talking myself into this. The getting everything at once might have flipped me. That way, we'll know if there any f*ck ups (truly hoping there aren't any) nice and quick instead of dragging it on. Plus, I'm interested to see if they really learned from their mistakes on A1. Plus, I f*cking love MOTOWN! :cool:
 
Well I'm definitely disappointed they're shipping all at once. That was a big part of why I liked the first antho...
I was torn on it. I liked them being shipped separately. I didn’t like not having liner notes up front nor did I like not knowing the album titles even though we kinda did know them...
 
If we have 8 (well, 9...) AAA LPs with hi-quality pressing and sleeves, the price point of the box itself (w/ discount) is not so unreasonable I'd say. I recently picked some Tone Poet releases for 35€ each (around 38$ - and FWIW they're among the best sounding record I have) so that's in-line with the box-set price (not discussing the Blue Note audiophile vs Motown thing here).
It sucks that the TP releases are so expensive in Europe! They do sound amazing though.

I really wonder what albums are in this box...and if they are hard to come by. BN was an instant buy for me because I couldn’t get even used copies in decent condition of some of those albums for under $40 and one was never released on vinyl. I hate the normalization of $40 single LP records nowadays.
 
Back
Top