Vinyl Me Please Essentials

BjorgenFjorgen said:
100% agreed. I can see the argument for Sky Blue Sky through The Whole Love being described as "dad rock" or "unadventurous" (though even the latter album has a few out-there tracks), but their last three have been anything but.
Click to expand...

You mean like "Bull Black Nova" off The Whole Love? Its as "adventurous" as anything Radiohead has done since Amnesic.
 
BjorgenFjorgen said:
100% agreed. I can see the argument for Sky Blue Sky through The Whole Love being described as "dad rock" or "unadventurous" (though even the latter album has a few out-there tracks), but their last three have been anything but.
Click to expand...
I get it somewhat, but even the adventurous moments on those albums are in that Wilco-esque groove that, to me, has become what I imagine as Dad Rock for Gen X'ers and Millenials. I get that part of this is a tribute to Wilco that they've created a sound that is so uniquely them. The term "hue" best describes it for me. It all feels part of the same template, even if it is different shadings and tempos.

FWIW, I'm in the Being There through A Ghost is Born can do no wrong camp (and YHF is a top 5 album of the 2000s), I think Sky Blue Sky is very good to excellent and everything that has followed has been good, but diminishing returns for me.
 
TenderLovingKiller® said:
I think it used to mean “shitty” rock music your dad listened to (preface: if you like any of the following groups please don’t take it as an insult and I actually enjoy some of this stuff too.) Artist like Journey, Chicago, Doobie Brothers, Styx, etc...but the term has evolved to represent like pleasant indie rock from career indie rock bands. It only feels like a slight to certain folks IMO because it congers up comparisons to the aforementioned groups and regardless whatever you think of Wilco and The National I would assume most would not include it in the same vein as Foreigner.
Click to expand...
I immediately associate Steely Dan w dad rock
 
The Commish said:
See, here is where the Stan in me comes out.

Wilco (the Album) thorugh Ode to Joy are no less (fill in your adjective of critical adulation here_________________), than: Mitski's Puberty2/Be the Cowboy or Julien Baker's Turn Out The Lights or Big Thief's Two Hands or Julia Jacklin's Crushing or Lucy Dacus' Historian or Better Oblivion Community Center or Waxahatchee's Out in the Storm or Hop Along's Bark, Your Head Off Dog or Courtney Barnett's' Tell Me How You Really Feel..

But, because its Wilco its "Dad Rock".
Click to expand...

Co-signing this.

I was a rabid Uncle Tupelo fan and have followed Wilco since the beginning. They have evolved in many ways (among other things, it has been rewarding to watch Jeff mature from a somewhat fragile, insecure punk to an elder statesman) and for me personally, would have to the be most impactful band of the past 25 years - but that may also be largely due to the fact that their career has spanned most of my adult life. Would also put Radiohead in the running - and, while they don't tick all of the boxes, Built to Spill has to be right up there (again, for me personally). I am in full agreement that Wilco's recorded peak was 'Being There' to 'A Ghost is Born' (the latter being my favorite). I have been largely underwhelmed since then, but would put their current live show up against anyone else. Wilco is and has been plenty adventurous, and "dad rock" feels like a bit of a cheap shot.

Oh, and yes, I too am a dad...hell, my oldest daughter had seen Wilco three times before her fourth birthday (at age 13, she is probably close to 10 Wilco shows and counting)...but I also listen to all types of music.
 
Last edited:
BjorgenFjorgen said:
100% agreed. I can see the argument for Sky Blue Sky through The Whole Love being described as "dad rock" or "unadventurous" (though even the latter album has a few out-there tracks), but their last three have been anything but.
Click to expand...
I think Sky Blue Sky was "out there" in how straight-laced it was in relations to everything that had preceded it. I remember being hugely disappointed upon my first listen and then at some point it clicked that SBS was almost their comedown/hangover record and once the expectations about what they were going for made sense to me I was able to enjoy it a great deal. Outside of a few songs on each album not withstanding, it was the last time any of their albums as a whole has really click with me. I think Tweedy is a genius but works best with a musical foil, Jay Bennett early on and Jim O'Rourke later. Since Jim left I haven't found them to be as dynamic. Not to say anything they have done is bad, far from it, other bands would kill to release a string of albums as good as Wilco's post-SBS output has been.
 
Ethos99 said:
Wait guys, wait... Where are we on The Decemberist, and the Avett brothers?
Click to expand...
I'd say Avett inhabits a corner of Dad Rock, but having seen them live, their audience skewed both younger and more female than I think could be classified as Dad Rock.

The Decemberists always struck me as a bit too quirky and folky to fit in the Dad Rock canon.

And before someone rages, I know I'm making gross over-characterizations and that everybody can listen to these groups, hardcore rap, and death metal without being confined to a label.
 
Indymisanthrope said:
The Avett Brothers, like RHCP, are a band that score well on multiple criteria but comes up short for me in the totals. And have only existed for about 60% of the timeframe under discussion. Give it another 10 years and see what happens? Maybe put My Morning Jacket in this bucket as well?
Click to expand...
MMJ is my first instinct for best rock band of the last 25 years, though they've certainly put out a sub-par album or two in that time.
 
Indymisanthrope said:
The Avett Brothers, like RHCP, are a band that score well on multiple criteria but comes up short for me in the totals. And have only existed for about 60% of the timeframe under discussion. Give it another 10 years and see what happens? Maybe put My Morning Jacket in this bucket as well?
Click to expand...

Yes! Thank you, I was trying to think of at least a third one.
 
Indymisanthrope said:
The Avett Brothers, like RHCP, are a band that score well on multiple criteria but comes up short for me in the totals. And have only existed for about 60% of the timeframe under discussion. Give it another 10 years and see what happens? Maybe put My Morning Jacket in this bucket as well?
Click to expand...
I think they fail on the album standpoint - enjoyable live band and some great tunes, but only one album that I think is better than the general good range.
 
BjorgenFjorgen said:
MMJ is my first instinct for best rock band of the last 25 years, though they've certainly put out a sub-par album or two in that time.
Click to expand...
Bearded Dad Rock.

In all seriousness, I think they're a strong contender for best of the last 25, certainly a Top 10 rock group during that period. The aforementioned albums of Z, At Dawn, and It Still Moves are great, but my favorite is the live album, Okonokos. Love that one.
 
Selaws said:
The Roots are one of those groups where once you scratch the surface you soon realize they have been so so so influential in the world of music. They have guided, produced, and assisted a crazy amount of now renown musicians including Erykah Badu, Common, D'Angelo (Voodoo won a Grammy), Jay-Z, Amy Winehouse, John Legend, Elvis Costello, Slum Village, etc. They have also worked on films and broadway shows, most notably 'Hamilton' (where The Roots are credited as producers). This is all before we even mention their own albums.

They have released 11 studio albums (9 of which ranked within the top 5 US R&B Charts, and 7 breaking the top 20 US Charts) 2EP's, and 3 collaborative albums (2 breaking the top 20 US Charts). They have 3 Grammy's (not including the Grammy won for Hamilton) plus countless other awards. Their live shows are constantly ranked as being amongst the best in the world, and the critical reviews match this claim. Its difficult to state their net worth from music alone, but Black Thought has a net value of $12Million and Questlove had $16Million. Its more than likely that a considerable chunk of this stems from their albums. I would also add that they are one of those groups where you may struggle to name a song by them, but they actually have a load of instantly recognizable songs.

I completely agree with you that a lot of people will only know them as 'Jimmy Fallon's House Band', but the reason they were offered that role is BECAUSE of their already stellar career. In fact, when first approaching them with the offer Fallon completely expected to be turned down by them, and it wasn't until Questlove turned the corner to see Fallon and the rest of the Roots messing around (they were on the floor making a human pyramid) that they agreed to be part of it (they thought it would be a good platform to remove the pressures of their other work and just play around).

This was a actually a fun exercise :LOL:
Click to expand...

This is a fantastic assessment, and you didn't even have to mention how amazing their live show has been for 25+ (?) years.

These guys are no strangers to taking an odd gig that probably pays very well. Seen them 3 times in 3 atypical situations: 1. Kool-sponsored event in Nashville (~2005, free menthols), 2. Music festival that my college sponsored also in Nashville (2007; The Roots, Wolfmother, and Drive-By Truckers headlined), 3. Jazz Fest after show at the Orpheum where they started at about 2:00am (2016; Anthony Mackie standing next to me, Craig Robinson also in attendance).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top