Vinyl Me Please (store, exclusives, swaps, etc)

I guess I should have known there wouldn't be two different ladies named Love Sex.

giphy%2B%25281%2529.gif
wait what?? well i messaged her first and Love Sex and I have the same taste in music.
 
It seems to only be former ROTMs that are in stock along with:
el-p
Hakim
Leithauser
Clams Casino
Khatib
(courtesy of @Tys1 )

The other interesting thing here is that it seems that they are closing out being able to get a $40 store exclusive for a $23 add-on now.

Sorry, I'm getting confused. Where did this list of what would be available come from @Tys1 ?
 
Sorry, I'm getting confused. Where did this list of what would be available come from @Tys1 ?


It was posted by VMP, at the very bottom of this

 
It was posted by VMP, at the very bottom of this


Thanks

This bit here got me

"Scroll down to see what options will be available this month when Swaps open on Tuesday, 5/26, at 3pm MT."

It's like they go out of the way so that nobody knows the drop time by announcing it in a different timezone each month
 
I wish they would let you do a "pause" like Secretly Society lets you do. With SS, if you don't like the album of the month, you can tell them to pause it for a month and they add a month at the end of your subscription.

I agree with this. Also, I think they should give everyone $27 credit when they swap for credit. I am an annual member, which is a bigger commitment, and I'll only get $23. Seems meh to me.
 
Last edited:
I agree with this. Also, I think they should give everyone $27 credit when they swap for credit. I am am annual member, which is a bigger commitment, and I'll only get $23. Seems meh to me.
I can see why they wouldn’t do this, but you raise a good point. If they keep this system, it essentially nullifies the need for a yearly membership. You can do monthly and just cash in on the good, high demand albums while “skipping” the poor ones.
 
I agree with this. Also, I think they should give everyone $27 credit when they swap for credit. I am an annual member, which is a bigger commitment, and I'll only get $23. Seems meh to me.
I had never received a store credit until I swapped for Jeff Buckley a couple months ago and they oversold. I have been an annual member since 2016 and they gave me a 40 dollar store credit. That's my one and only credit so far so not sure if that is the standard or not.
 
As someone who opts in and out of VMP and sees their store exclusives as a much bigger pull than their AOTM, this is an incredible change if implemented as they suggest.

I can basically treat it like a crate subscription that I can easily switch to picking one of the AOTM if it interests me. This might tempt me to being a member full time.

My only worry is that they will only give credits based on US costs (eg $27, when it would cost international $36).
 
I had never received a store credit until I swapped for Jeff Buckley a couple months ago and they oversold. I have been an annual member since 2016 and they gave me a 40 dollar store credit. That's my one and only credit so far so not sure if that is the standard or not.

With the swap for credits, your annual membership will net you $23, if I understand correctly.
 
As someone who opts in and out of VMP and sees their store exclusives as a much bigger pull than their AOTM, this is an incredible change if implemented as they suggest.

I can basically treat it like a crate subscription that I can easily switch to picking one of the AOTM if it interests me. This might tempt me to being a member full time.

My only worry is that they will only give credits based on US costs (eg $27, when it would cost international $36).
The downside to all of this though is that it seems you would no longer be able to add on a track to get a store exclusive for $23. It seems by limiting swaps it might be trickier to get those addons for way cheaper. My buddy is going to see if he can add on Shabaka for me...but I’m not so sure he will be able to for $23.
 
That seems like a bum deal. There's a reason they regularly give $40 in store credits when they screw up. Even they know their stuff is overpriced. The only thing you can buy with $23 is stuff they can't get rid of.
Have you received a 40 dollar credit each time? I just have the one experience.
 
I wish. They took it away after a few of us racked up quite a few. 😄
Someone mentioned it’s back and you have to email but honestly my buddy asked me about it because he wanted to join after getting a turntable about 5 months ago. I said the record quality is good but if you have issues it’s hard to get them fixed. He got a 3 month sub, bought a lot of stuff and had a miserable experience so I would feel bad referring people to sign up anyway.
 
Have you received a 40 dollar credit each time? I just have the one experience.
Nope. I never have. Just seems common lately based on the comments here.

I've usually had a replacement sent for my issues. I've been lucky to never have been a victim of overselling. One time they only gave me $15 for jacket damage. Recently they let me pick a free record and were happy to give me one priced at $39.

By pricing many of the past ROTMs, which members get from $23-27 dollars a month at $40 in the store, they are either saying you get a good deal for being a member or blatantly showing members their store prices are inflated, depending how you look at it. If all they give you for passing on a month is $23 credit, they are not giving you an equivalent value based on their own pricing. If they gave you back $23 cash, that is another story and would be great.
 
Last edited:
Nope. I never have. Just seems common lately based on see comments here.

I've usually had a replacement sent for my issues. I've been lucky to never have been a victim of overselling. One time they only gave me $15 for jacket damage. Recently they let me pick a free record and were happy to give me one priced at $39.

By pricing many of the past ROTMs, which members get from $23-27 dollars a month at $40 in the store, they are either saying you get a good deal for being a member or blatantly showing members their store prices are inflated, depending how you look at it. If all they give you for passing on a month is $23 credit, they are not giving you an equivalent value based on their own pricing. If they gave you back $23 cash, that is another story and would be great.
Yea. Adding another track and swapping for $23 was always a great deal and I bought way more than I would have if that wasn’t an option. If they are now saying you can only swap for previous ROTM or get a $27 credit, well you can’t even buy any previous ROTM albums for $27 later on. This sucks for all customers. It’s not a bonus, it’s a money grab that benefits the customers in no way.

I believe the $40 credit has only happened once with the oversold swaps.
 
Back
Top