Vinyl Me Please (store, exclusives, swaps, etc)

roffle24 said:
I mean realistically VMP should be pressing what they think is best for their members, not what their internal staff wants for their personal collection. Nilsson doesn't do anything for me so I guess I'm bias in that regard, but the albums seem to have done well in the store so I guess it's a win/win for Storf.
Click to expand...
Can’t it be both? That they press stuff they think their members will like AND have it be stuff that the curators like and want in their collections? Taste in curation is gonna be subjective no matter and won’t please all members. I don’t like a lot of what gets chosen as ROTMs (or don’t feel the need to buy it at the price they are charging). The Nilsson store exclusives at least have sold well. I think one Nilsson ROTM would have been enough and the others should have been done as limited store exclusives personally.
 
MikeH said:
Can’t it be both? That they press stuff they think their members will like AND have it be stuff that the curators like and want in their collections? Taste in curation is gonna be subjective no matter and won’t please all members. I don’t like a lot of what gets chosen as ROTMs (or don’t feel the need to buy it at the price they are charging). The Nilsson store exclusives at least have sold well. I think one Nilsson ROTM would have been enough and the others should have been done as limited store exclusives personally.
Click to expand...

I think you could have got away with the two Nilsson’s if you didn’t have his piss poor lost weekend album in which he destroyed his voice as the essential.

It can be both but there needs to be more self awareness. There are loads of out of print albums I’d like to see repressed but I’d like to hope in that position that I’d have the ability to distinguish between stuff I think other people want and completionist collection padding for myself and that my employer would hold me to account on slow sales for the later. If you really are going to do the later it should not be be in a subscription track, do a small number pressing for the store.
 
Last edited:
MikeH said:
Can’t it be both? That they press stuff they think their members will like AND have it be stuff that the curators like and want in their collections? Taste in curation is gonna be subjective no matter and won’t please all members. I don’t like a lot of what gets chosen as ROTMs (or don’t feel the need to buy it at the price they are charging). The Nilsson store exclusives at least have sold well. I think one Nilsson ROTM would have been enough and the others should have been done as limited store exclusives personally.
Click to expand...

Way too many nilssons, i got the first 3 they did and that was good enough for me, nilsson burnout
 
Elric of Melnibone said:
Way too many nilssons, i got the first 3 they did and that was good enough for me, nilsson burnout
Click to expand...
yea--just because they COULD do that many nilssons didn't mean they SHOULD.

Joe Mac said:
I think you could have got away with the two Nilsson’s if you didn’t have his piss poor lost weekend album in which he destroyed his voice as the essential.

It can be both but there needs to be more self awareness. There are loads of out of print albums I’d like to see repressed but I’d like to hope in that position that I’d have the ability to distinguish between stuff I think other people want and completionist collection padding for myself and that my employer would hold me to account on slow sales for the later. If you really are going to do the later it should not be be in a subscription track, do a small number pressing for the store.
Click to expand...


i don't doubt that it's becoming harder and harder (and more expensive) to license certain OOP albums especially stuff that is in high demand. Everybody wants a big piece of the pie and labels like Interscope now have their own reissue series so most of those titles are off limits. Hoping they can get some more variety with good albums that are harder to find. Classics has been largely solid still for me. Country is hit or miss (but I'm not a HUGE country fan). Don't buy the RHH stuff. Rock and essentials has been a mixed bag. I usually get 1 album a month which i'm fine with since i was on the deal with all the free records. not sure if i'll reup next year at all or just pop in and out.

I know they are going to hand off some curation duties to some other folks as well in the near future. the more voices in curation, the better IMO.
 
MikeH said:
yea--just because they COULD do that many nilssons didn't mean they SHOULD.




i don't doubt that it's becoming harder and harder (and more expensive) to license certain OOP albums especially stuff that is in high demand. Everybody wants a big piece of the pie and labels like Interscope now have their own reissue series so most of those titles are off limits. Hoping they can get some more variety with good albums that are harder to find. Classics has been largely solid still for me. Country is hit or miss (but I'm not a HUGE country fan). Don't buy the RHH stuff. Rock and essentials has been a mixed bag. I usually get 1 album a month which i'm fine with since i was on the deal with all the free records. not sure if i'll reup next year at all or just pop in and out.

I know they are going to hand off some curation duties to some other folks as well in the near future. the more voices in curation, the better IMO.
Click to expand...

Yeah I get that but they’ve been all over the place with curation for a long long long time. They were making odd decisions 5, 6, 7, 8 years ago before the likes of rhino and craft took it in house and mofi and fuck chad blew up to be much bigger operations than just catnip for the likes of ole slow vape.

Also let’s be honest. Pussy Cats wasn’t licensing. It was Storf thinking he was being edgy or interesting or cool when in reality he just dropped a turd into 20,000 subscribers mail boxes. He has been their biggest issue for years.
 
Joe Mac said:
Yeah I get that but they’ve been all over the place with curation for a long long long time. They were making odd decisions 5, 6, 7, 8 years ago before the likes of rhino and craft took it in house and mofi and fuck chad blew up to be much bigger operations than just catnip for the likes of ole slow vape.

Also let’s be honest. Pussy Cats wasn’t licensing. It was Storf thinking he was being edgy or interesting or cool when in reality he just dropped a turd into 20,000 subscribers mail boxes.
Click to expand...
i agree on pussy cats even though i like the album. i don't like it enough to pay $40 though hah. that seemed like a "this is a fun story" over "this is a great, essential album that everyone should have in their collection".
 
MikeH said:
i agree on pussy cats even though i like the album. i don't like it enough to pay $40 though hah. that seemed like a "this is a fun story" over "this is a great, essential album that everyone should have in their collection".
Click to expand...

Yeah but the music has to come first. Two drunk and high lads fucking about and one destroying his voice isn’t putting the music first. If the music doesn’t support the story then just don’t.
 
Joe Mac said:
Yeah but the music has to come first. Two drunk and high lads fucking about and one destroying his voice isn’t putting the music first. If the music doesn’t support the story then just don’t.
Click to expand...
definitely agree. the album seems like an interesting trivia fact vs an album that should be in their most pressed track. should have been a store exclusive if anything.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top