Vinyl Me Please Essentials

bdrummond said:
I don't think it rules it out. The game is to guess them all correctly in one submission. 8/12 means they could've gotten it right, but failed on at least 4 other picks somewhere. I'm not interpreting this to mean 4/12 have not been guessed yet.
Click to expand...
Have a lot of folks been guessing all 12 at once? I'm not really tracking the process beyond the conversation here.
 
pdro_logn said:
Damn. Yep. I forgot about that clue.
Click to expand...
Even then the clues become a bit wacky.
"Montreal" being a geographical locale could refer to Grimes, Mac Demarco and Patrick Watson depending on how you classify that. All were not born there, and only Patrick Watson is outright described as a Montreal musician.

If it IS somehow Patrick Watson, then the solo clue is technically wrong.
 
bdrummond said:
Yes, it's possible. For the essentials picks alone one has a possibility of three different albums, and the other two. One of the hip hop tracks I know for sure still has two possible guesses (Ice T and DOC)...I think Classics aside from possibly Chic is wide open. Not sure about Country.

Guessing them all correctly in one go is a challenge.
Click to expand...

I think Country is probably the easiest of the tracks to figure out (it helps that Lyle Lovett put out a press release saying his album would be a VMP ROTM for March). The biggest question is which of two possible Loretta Lynn albums is February.

hatfieldpdx said:
Have a lot of folks been guessing all 12 at once? I'm not really tracking the process beyond the conversation here.
Click to expand...
For the contest (which I assume is what Storf is referring to) you have to put in all 12 at once. The plus side is you can guess as many times as you want so theoretically you can do multiple submissions where you're only changing out one or two of your guesses.

I think where people are getting hung up the most is January Classics (which I feel could be about a half dozen different things) but also I'm not sure about March Classics (I think it's Lightin' Hopkins but it's possible it might not be the album we think it is), February Essentials, or March Hip-Hop.
 
NewsFedora said:
I think Country is probably the easiest of the tracks to figure out (it helps that Lyle Lovett put out a press release saying his album would be a VMP ROTM for March). The biggest question is which of two possible Loretta Lynn albums is February.


For the contest (which I assume is what Storf is referring to) you have to put in all 12 at once. The plus side is you can guess as many times as you want so theoretically you can do multiple submissions where you're only changing out one or two of your guesses.

I think where people are getting hung up the most is January Classics (which I feel could be about a half dozen different things) but also I'm not sure about March Classics (I think it's Lightin' Hopkins but it's possible it might not be the album we think it is), February Essentials, or March Hip-Hop.
Click to expand...
Ah thanks, didn't realize there was an actual contest at play. Thought it was just an old fashioned guess-a-palooza.
 
bdrummond said:
Even then the clues become a bit wacky.
"Montreal" being a geographical locale could refer to Grimes, Mac Demarco and Patrick Watson depending on how you classify that. All were not born there, and only Patrick Watson is outright described as a Montreal musician.

If it IS somehow Patrick Watson, then the solo clue is technically wrong.
Click to expand...

most of my locals put Rufus Wainwright under "Indie / Alternative", he's definitely a solo artist and as Montreal as they get. just saying
 
bdrummond said:
Definitely...honestly though I'd be shocked if they picked Out of the Game.
Click to expand...

doesn't he have a much broader appeal than, say, Patrick Watson? the fact that he's being mentioned here is basically the only reason why I thought of Rufus - I just don't think Patrick is that famous or even known (outside of Canada and some European countries) to be anywhere near the Essentials label
 
radiojazzz said:
doesn't he have a much broader appeal than, say, Patrick Watson? the fact that he's being mentioned here is basically the only reason why I thought of Rufus - I just don't think Patrick is that famous or even known (outside of Canada and some European countries) to be anywhere near the Essentials label
Click to expand...
If spotify stats are to be believed Patrick Watson has about 4x the monthly listeners as Rufus. He's more well known than I think you realize.
 
bdrummond said:
If spotify stats are to be believed Patrick Watson has about 4x the monthly listeners as Rufus. He's more well known than I think you realize.
Click to expand...
yeah, maybe. it's hard to be objective when you bump into him on a daily basis ) but you're right, naming him a solo act would be strange - Patrick Watson is a band, always has been, it just happens to be named after its singer
 
radiojazzz said:
yeah, maybe. it's hard to be objective when you bump into him on a daily basis ) but you're right, naming him a solo act would be strange - Patrick Watson is a band, always has been, it just happens to be named after its singer
Click to expand...
Yeah, and that's why I've said before if that's what it is and someone misses that ONE pick then go after VMP on it. It's totally a mistake that they would make when making up the clues and it would not surprise me at all if they did. The fact that there are prizes involved should make them really do their research before putting the clues out into the open, but I highly doubt they would.
 
Looking back at the clues, there is a lot of room for interpretation here that kind of annoys me now that they are offering prize incentives for them.

Saying an act is "associated with" a city is pretty broad. Someone actually guessed Blur for the Icelandic band as Damon Albarn received Icelandic citizenship. Both front runners (and the Patrick Watson guess too) for the solo Montreal pick aren't even born in Montreal, just live there at some point.

Why is "indie rock" in quotes? What does that even mean?

"Depending on how you count" isn't a proper clue.

Iunno, if I'm making a contest I'm going to leave no room for dispute. VMP on the other hand still manages to be vague while raising the stakes.
 
bdrummond said:
Looking back at the clues, there is a lot of room for interpretation here that kind of annoys me now that they are offering prize incentives for them.

Saying an act is "associated with" a city is pretty broad. Someone actually guessed Blur for the Icelandic band as Damon Albarn received Icelandic citizenship. Both front runners (and the Patrick Watson guess too) for the solo Montreal pick aren't even born in Montreal, just live there at some point.

Why is "indie rock" in quotes? What does that even mean?

"Depending on how you count" isn't a proper clue.

Iunno, if I'm making a contest I'm going to leave no room for dispute. VMP on the other hand still manages to be vague while raising the stakes.
Click to expand...
So it's DEFINITELY storf then
 
bdrummond said:
Looking back at the clues, there is a lot of room for interpretation here that kind of annoys me now that they are offering prize incentives for them.

Saying an act is "associated with" a city is pretty broad. Someone actually guessed Blur for the Icelandic band as Damon Albarn received Icelandic citizenship. Both front runners (and the Patrick Watson guess too) for the solo Montreal pick aren't even born in Montreal, just live there at some point.

Why is "indie rock" in quotes? What does that even mean?

"Depending on how you count" isn't a proper clue.

Iunno, if I'm making a contest I'm going to leave no room for dispute. VMP on the other hand still manages to be vague while raising the stakes.
Click to expand...
It's a great way to minimize the chances of someone actually winning. They're not doing any kind of drawing, it's "you gotta get them all right and you have to be the very first person to do so."
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top