2024 Reading Challenge

Sad book September has come to a close.

31. Lincoln in the Bardo by George Saunders - Appreciated this on its radical form, and what it was going for (creating an emotional throughline in history), but found it more fascinating than affecting. The toilet humor didn't really mesh with the otherwise profound ruminations on death and grieving. Still interested in checking out other Saunders though.

32. Stoner by John Williams - Just finished this tonight and thought it was absolutely incredible. Probably a new all-timer for me. Stirring and haunting look at a normal guy's life that kind of sucks, but still full of meaning. Gorgeous, sparse prose. Teared up several times. Feel like I have to reevaluate my life after this one. Anybody here read it?

Had a couple horror novels planned next for the season, but idk, we'll see. I feel like I need to read something happy soon. lol
Lincoln in the Bardo is one of the best and most original novels from this century that I've read. I just picked up a hardcover copy over the weekend and am looking forward to a re-read, possibly with the audiobook that has a million notable names playing parts. I haven't read any of his short stories yet, but will definitely be doing so.

Read Stoner a couple years ago and enjoyed it but don't have any desire to return to it, and I don't think that's just because of how bleak it was. Its "underrated/underread" reputation has become a running joke on book twitter that it's swung back again: "oh we're doing Stoner discourse again." I do really want to read Butcher's Crossing, though.
 
Lincoln in the Bardo is one of the best and most original novels from this century that I've read. I just picked up a hardcover copy over the weekend and am looking forward to a re-read, possibly with the audiobook that has a million notable names playing parts. I haven't read any of his short stories yet, but will definitely be doing so.

I listened to the audiobook (quite a while ago), and with all the different voice actors doing the myriad roles it is definitely an experience.
 
Anyone here read Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow? Reading it now, a little less than halfway in…it’s not a bad read but it just is kinda….nothing? Is the rest of the book this uneventful?

It’s on my list and I know I’d love it but the audiobook’s voice actor was not good and I couldn’t imagine listening to such a long book with them. Hopefully soon I’ll find the time to sit done and read it
 
Yes!

I love both of these, but am a particularly strong supporter of Stoner, since it seems especially unheralded (maybe a metaphor for Professor Stoner?). I came across that one a few years back (I think Hamilton Leithauser of the Walkmen, of all people, recommended it), and then pushed it on so many people. Despite all that happens (and doesn't happen) to Stoner, I found it strangely uplifting?

Edit: found the Leithauser recommendation. It was more than a few years back, apparently:

Stoner by John Williams: My favorite book I read this year. He has a plain-Jane, perfectly mild style that is so satisfying. It’s like a great roasted chicken. It’s the life story of a guy named Stoner, who comes to work in the academic world, and is basically screwed over from all sides time and time again. Between his wife and the dean of students, he’s just not catching any breaks. There is less humor here than, say the Coen brothers’ A Serious Man, but the matter-of-fact storytelling hooked me like a fish. I didn’t know a thing about John Williams beforehand, but after reading Stoner, I picked up Augustus (which I also recommend) and Butcher’s Crossing (which I haven’t yet read).

Lincoln in the Bardo is one of the best and most original novels from this century that I've read. I just picked up a hardcover copy over the weekend and am looking forward to a re-read, possibly with the audiobook that has a million notable names playing parts. I haven't read any of his short stories yet, but will definitely be doing so.

Read Stoner a couple years ago and enjoyed it but don't have any desire to return to it, and I don't think that's just because of how bleak it was. Its "underrated/underread" reputation has become a running joke on book twitter that it's swung back again: "oh we're doing Stoner discourse again." I do really want to read Butcher's Crossing, though.
I agree that it's maybe not as bleak as it outwardly seems.

He has a mundane, not very pleasant life, but he gets by with a lot of small victories. He's a successful, admired professor. He experiences love despite his unhappy marriage. He holds strong and shows courage to people who would put him down. He has long term friends. I think it's as much about life's small victories as much as how it can easily slip through your fingers. And its difficulties in general: every character in this book is struggling against their circumstances in one way or another.

Anyway, will absolutely be reading both Augustus and Butcher's Crossing toom it's interesting how his 3 novels are all entirely different genres.
 
Book 24: Unapologetic Expression, The Inside Story of the UK Jazz by Andre Marmot (Faber & Faber, 2024)

I have been waiting for this book to be released for a while, having been following Andre on Instagram for a while. It certainly didn't disappoint and was a fantastic look into the history of the UK jazz scene (well, the UK music scene in general really with a focus on London). Really incredible book.

IMG_4887.JPG

Book 25: Yellowface by Rebecca F Kuang (The Borough Press, 2023)

I found this book really interesting as the main character is unlikable, but its written in a way that at times you are rooting for her, only to catch yourself realising how horrible she is. The ending was really disappointing though and seems rushed or unfinished which is quite disappointing.

IMG_5127.JPG

Book 26: The Vinyl Detective, Low Action by Andrew Cartmel (Titan Books, 2020)


I really enjoy this series and find them so easy to read. Its a fantastic mix of records, detective work, murder, mystery, the works!

IMG_5128.JPG

Book 27: The Jazz Life by Nat Hentoff (Panther, 1964)

I got through this book in a couple of days, it was an effortless read and fascinating as well. Hentoff references another book quite a lot within his and its next on my reading list.

IMG_5287.JPG

Book 28: Days at the Morisaki Bookshop by Satoshi Yagisawa (Manilla Press, 2023)

Another easy read that I borrowed from my wife. Its one of these books in which nothing really happens but its such a great, laid back read anyway. Top stuff.

IMG_5315.JPG

Book 29: The Vinyl Detective, Attack and Decay by Andrew Cartmel (Titan Books, 2022)

Another super fun book In the Vinyl Detective series, I cant get enough of these!
IMG_5522.JPG
 
Books 26-28 (with #20 still slogging away in the hedgerows of Normandy). Been a slow 6 weeks of reading lately
#26 - James S. A. Corey - Mercy of the Gods - a big fan of The Expanse series but this one did not grab me.
IMG_0542.jpg
#27 - Gerald Seymour - Foot Soldiers - A much better replacement for Le Carre than Mick Herron
IMG_0543.jpg
#28 - Francis Spufford - Cahokia Jazz - A recommendation from this thread. Great read. I enjoy Alternative History books, especially when they don't get bogged down with details. A great hard boiled/noir mystery, hopefully there is a sequel.
IMG_0545.jpg
 
For those into a bit of nonfiction:

I just finished listening to this book (Hope for Cynics: The Surprising Science of Human Goodness by Jamil Zaki). Basically, it's an argument against cynicism (the modern version, not the ancient Greek one) by showing how cooperation and skeptical hope lead to much better outcomes and a more accurate view of other people, all backed up by studies and data (complete with an appendix rating the quality of the evidence for each claim). I particularly liked how he argues that the antidote to cynicism is not hope, but healthy skepticism and an openness to ideas, data, and trust.

 
Started this last night. I kept seeing it in bookstores and thought it looked interesting.

9780593744178__59391.1726464390.jpg
This was so good. A really compelling story that would make a great Netflix or HBO documentary. Next is one I've been putting off but it keeps coming up on Best Of lists.

41SjBd5jIPL._SY445_SX342_.jpg
 
Book 20: A Game of Thrones, by George R.R. Martin
View attachment 212857
Consider this my ultimate acquiescence to George never finishing the series, as I’ve been holding out on a reread for the occasion of the publication of The Winds of Winter. I’ve felt fairly certain it isn’t coming, but that’s something I’ll expound upon as I run the series through Dance With Dragons.

But GoT itself: it’s hard to read this book on its own merits; it’s like watching Star Wars and viewing it as simply “Star Wars,” not “Star Wars: Episode 4: A New Hope.” This is a worldbuilding exercise and a setting-up of pieces on the board, and thus a little difficult to separate out from the payoffs and revelations later in the series.

A few years back I read GRRM’s outline/pitch for the series, and reading GoT with it in mind shows the possible simplicity of the originally-planned trilogy. It’s wild just how much runway is given for (not a spoiler if you’ve watched the show) RT+LS=JS in these pages; Ned Stark thinks back on his sister’s death often, and you can see how he’s holding back just enough truth.

In all, what I find most interesting about GoT and ASoIaF in general is that the story is about the aftermath of the previous battle for the Iron Throne; everyone is living with the consequences of a war from a dozen years ago. This is a medieval history nerd trying to thread the needle between entertainment and old-fashioned epic.

Book 21: Martyr!, by Kaveh Akhbar
View attachment 212855
There's quite a lot to enjoy here, plenty of depth to the prose and introspection which only a poet could really drill into. The structure is adventurous, moves quickly. Yet the conceit of the interludes, hypothetical conversations dreamt up by the author-insert protagonist between personages real and fictional, belies the singleness of the voices across the work; you get a lot of characters prevaricating in agreement with one another.

I found myself yearning for the exegesis of Akbar's exploration of death/martyrdom to the extent that I felt kind of frustrated by the whip-crack of plot development which occurs near the end; the book feels so unconcerned with story (which is fine) that the story which rears its head feels a bit unwelcome. I think there's 220 pages of great book hidden in this good 330 page book.


Book 22: Ripley's Game, by Patricia Highsmith
Book 3 of Highsmith’s Ripliad; I’ve been on a kick since Netflix’s exquisite Ripley limited (I hope that qualifier is soon inaccurate) series, as well as having caught Wim Wenders’s The American Friend on Criterion a month or two back. After a terminally ill art framer lightly snubs him at a social event, Ripley passes said framer’s name to a friend who’s looking for a hired killer. A lovely little friendship ensues; Strangers on a Train meets I Love You Man. Malkovich’s briefly-seen character from Ripley (‘24) factors in heavily here; seriously, Netflix: you have four more seasons to make. Don’t blow this.

Book 23: The Hearing Trumpet, by Leonora Carrington
View attachment 212856
A vibe, to be sure. Carrington, known best as a surrealist painter, apparently hung with Alejandro Jodorowsky, which inspires my logline: this book is like if The Holy Mountain was a novel about the Jim Broadbent section of Cloud Atlas. The story concerns a woman in her nineties who is sent to live in a surreal retirement community, where the residents live in buildings shaped like teapots and mushrooms. There’s a search for the Holy Grail, an apocalyptic ice age, and the discovery of a uranium mine under a kitchen.

Recently I’ve been at a place with surrealism where I’ve quit finding meaning; in the case of some artists like David Lynch I think the resulting feeling is more important than the meaning or intention, while a Jodorowsky gives me more an impression of someone deliberately throwing images at me without thought but rather an intention of thoughtfulness (if that makes sense; I dunno, I just saw Holy Mountain and found it to be silly nonsense (nonderogatory)). So I just went along for the ride here.
Book 24: A Clash of Kings, by George RR Martin
IMG_5024.jpeg

I remember really enjoying this one first time around but wow did it take me a while to get through. There are some good expansions of the world, especially in the five kings warring for the throne and some extra magic getting sprinkled in. It’s wild that there are only 4 Daenerys chapters across the book; pretty few Jon Snows as well. I love the Renly plot (I forgot how they made the deep subtext of his sexuality in the book more explicit in the show), as well as the Winterfell plot. Weird to think of the show and how far it got from the second season to the final one.

Book 25: The Auctioneer, by Joan Samson
IMG_5027.jpeg

And thus Scary Book season begins. I’m now on the other end of it (got burnt out by books 27 and 28), but this was a great start. This book apparently was a hit in the 70s when it came out but fell out of print, only coming back recently as part of the Paperbacks from Hell imprint.

The story concerns rural life in the 70s, focusing on a young couple and their daughter who move in with the husband’s aging mother on his childhood farm. A charismatic auctioneer comes to town, moves into a recently-vacated (under mysterious and violent circumstances) home, and starts regular auctions to help fund the police force. At first he accepts donations of unwanted items, but soon he starts requesting more than the townsfolk can give…

An interesting story for sure, and subtly chilling for how not-supernatural it insists on remaining. This is definitely a tale concerned with how far normal people can be pushed, mixed with some classic mob mentality. I will say it drags in the middle, as the protagonists waffle back and forth on whether to stand up for themselves or leave; for the most part they argue themselves into doing neither.

Book 26: Peace, by Gene Wolfe
IMG_5028.jpeg

There’s an inescapable Neil Gaiman (sigh) quote which follows this book around, that it comes across as nostalgic on first read, but reveals itself as a horror story on subsequent readings.

The story concerns the memories of an older man who (and I knew this going into the story and even Wolfe has acknowledged this, which he rarely does with his twists/mysteries, but I will spoiler-tag it inline) is a long-dead ghost. As he sifts through his life events the reader is invited to question the nature of his relationships, as well as the nature of certain partings. I’m listening to a podcast discussion/analysis right now, so I’m still unraveling some of the aspects of the story I didn’t pick up on.

I will say I had a rare experience with this one: I was reading it before bed and in a section where, in typical Gene Wolfe fashion, someone in-story has started to tell a story of their own (this particular one was in quite an interesting voice, as the teller is not very imaginative and will describe details as being “indescribable”), about taking up lodging in a new town. Before I knew it, creepy things were taking place, I was reading a ghost story, and found myself actually having to read ahead to get to a not-creepy place so I could sleep. It’s been a while since that’s happened.

Book 27: Beloved, by Toni Morrison
IMG_5026.jpeg

A literary ghost story! My second Morrison, after last year’s Summer of Solomon. I hate to say it but I didn’t enjoy this book as much as I did Song of Solomon; the way the story is told is some combination of suggestion and repetition, so you find yourself trying to recall whether events/scenes/quotes are appearing the first time in full, or if this is actually your first hint of them. That certainly makes for an effective look at history and trauma, but I had trouble getting my arms around this one.

Book 28: Perfect Union, by Cody Goodfellow
IMG_5025.jpeg

A dip into the world of New Weird fiction, I’ve been hearing about Goodfellow in general, and this story sounded nutty: tasked with helping his twin brothers in-law move their mother (his mother in-law), a man finds himself swept up in a war between opposing cults which model themselves off bee colonies. The natures of the cults are a bit difficult to parse, especially as their political standpoints are data-dumped on us in a break between action sequences.

Speaking of, this book really taps into an issue I have with a lot of horror literature, which is that while the setup is a bit creepy, the story eventually shifts into action mode as our protagonist faces whatever evil is at play.

Overall I felt like I was too old for this book; the weird/taboo stuff is more edgy and gross for its own sake (lots o pants shittin), the characters are pretty unpleasant, and any political subtext is plain old text.
 
Last edited:
Book 13: Rosemary’s Baby by Ira Levin

IMG_5495.jpeg

Given that it’s spooky month I just had to read something horror to fit the mood (and it’s a really fun coincidence that this is book #13). Earlier this month I watched the movie of this for the first time and thought it was an absolute masterpiece, and for the days after I could not stop thinking about it and how upset it had made me, so I thought the source material would be the perfect book to go with. And just like the movie it was a masterpiece that has left me incredibly upset lol. One of my favorite aspects of the book is that Rosemary is actually really smart and figures things out, but she is so powerless that is doesn’t matter. The powerful people around her successfully manipulate her and take any power away so she can’t stop them. Just so upsetting and still so relevant. Also Minnie is an all time great character

Rating - 5/5
 
Book #14 - The Honeys by Ryan La Sala

IMG_5545.jpeg

Defiantly needed to go with another spooky book for this month and this one sounded really interesting. Horror that takes place in broad daylight and in natural settings fascinate more than most horror does. Added on to that lgbt themes and a bunch of creepy mean girls and I was sold. And If you asked me at chapter 30 I probably would have given this a 5/5. Everything from the mystery, the supernatural aspects and the romance are all slow burns that I found too slow in the middle but as I was nearing the end it was all coming together perfectly. And then the last few chapters happened. Not bad necessarily and within context it does make sense. But it just felt rushed and unfocused. Too many antagonists with too many conflicting agendas and not enough plot to make them all interesting. If it just focused on the most interesting aspects of the story it could have been an all time favorite. I still enjoyed this experience but not as much as I could’ve

Rating - 3.5/5
 
October 2024

Book 60: Stephen King - The Dead Zone

thumbnail_IMG_2733.jpg
King really can tell a great story but, disappointingly following The Stand, I found the quality of writing in this one really piss-poor. His descriptive writing felt like it was straight from a high-schooler's English exercise, the dialogue was frequently cringe-worthy as if from an episode of Happy Days and any references to sex felt like they came from someone whose only prior experience involved issues of Playboy. Top notch story though, albeit one that I was already familiar with because of the movie adaptation, and it entertained from start to finish.

Book 61: Susan Hill - The Woman in Black
thumbnail_IMG_2734.jpg
Masterful use of suspense to create the horror here. Very enjoyable but, even at only ~150pp I thought this might have fared better as a bona fide short story as the build up started to feel a bit repetitive with the village locals continually showing themselves to be all knowing but, remaining reluctant to speak up to the big city stranger. Good October read nontheless.

Book 62: John Berendt - Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
thumbnail_IMG_2735.jpg
I’ve been adding true crime books to my October reads - nothing seems more horrifying than the things humans seem to be prepared to do to one another. I can totally see why this has remained such a popular book since publication. It’s incredibly well written and immensely entertaining throughout. I’m a bit more surprised that it consistently crops up on best true crime book lists however, given that out of the ~400pp, only maybe 30 or so relate directly to a crime and the consequent efforts at punishment. The rest is a love letter to Savannah and the wonderfully quirky people that live there. Berendt’s journalistic background shines through and he delivers more of a detailed travelogue to me than a true crime piece. So, while this may not have been what I was expecting for an October read, I thoroughly enjoyed every sentence and would gladly recommend to anyone interested in unique people and places.

Book 63: Catherine Pelonero - Kitty Genovese
thumbnail_IMG_2736.jpg
I knew the basics of the Kitty Genovese murder but this book did a fabulous job of laying out the events of that tragic night, the history of the main players and the subsequent trial. It also looked further into the developments in criminology and psychology due to the behaviour of the witnesses during the murder. Good true crime book.

Book 64: Thomas Preskett Prest - The String of Pearls
thumbnail_IMG_2737.jpg
This 'penny dreadful' was alright. The Sweeney Todd story is one I've been aware of for as long as I can remember but, only told as a person to person folk tale, almost as if he were a real person and his misdeeds were a cautionary tale about the darker side of the our capital. While I knew he was actually fiction, I didn't know until recently that this was the original source material. Like many originally serialised books of the period, (even the greats likes Dickens' which I'm no expert in but have read a few), this seemed to me to be unnecessarily prolonged and frequently repetitive as it subtly reminded the reader from the previous month what is important. It is a gruesome tale though so kudos to whoever thought it up, (I've read that Prest who Penguin credits is frequently questioned as the true anonymous author).

Book 65: Gaston Leroux - The Phantom of the Opera
thumbnail_IMG_2738.jpg
I found this a bit boring to be honest. Another one that perhaps I knew just enough of before reading for the actual material to be just a bit underwhelming. I finished my month off with 4 days in Paris so this tale set inside the Paris Opera House seemed like the perfect accompaniment but, it just failed to grasp me and any terror was sadly foiled by the moments of farce between arguing theatre managers and Clouseauesque detective! Not terrible, just nothing special.
 
Back
Top