I watched this earlier and completely agree with the points Ken raises.
Essentially he watched a live stream by a prominent audiophile collector on Youtube and someone asked which jazz labels are best avoided. The Youtuber's response was "If you stick to the audiophile labels then you will be fine". The response clearly irked Ken and I have to admit that I feel the same way. There seem to be more and more people that dismiss any pressings other than high-end audiophiles.
The Youtuber in question supposedly has only been buying records for 1 year and has more than I do, full runs of the Music Matters jazz (and SRX titles), all of the URQR's, all of the Tone Poets, and a system that likely cost 10s of thousands if not more. Now I don't begrudge this at all (I would be the same if I had the money) but surely if you are in the 'game' for the music then you really are limiting yourself massively. I love a good reissue as much as anyone but can think of several albums on 'cheaper' labels that beat titles released on analogue labels.
Maybe I'm looking into it more than I should be but it's certainly something I have noticed on Instagram lately. People will say things like "this is definitely the best sounding copy available" which comparing 2 modern reissues.
Points well taken on the fact that ignoring non-audiophile labels is problematic for several reasons. Ken’s taken a couple shots at the YouTuber you’re talking about (45rpmAudiophile), as has The Jazz Shepherd. I watch all 3 of those channels — and I enjoy all of them for different reasons.
However, their criticisms come off (to me) as childish and petty, bc they don’t like his style (he merely shows his collection without giving substantive reviews), and, I think, are envious of his much larger subscriber numbers. But that’s what he wants to do, and many people enjoy it (including me). And he’s turned me on to several amazing electronic releases I would not have known about by Nicholas Jaar, Darkside, Thomas Fehlmann, and, in the jazz realm, I think he’s the reason I have “Ron Jefferson Choir” and “Glass Bead Games.”
More to Ken’s comment about limiting acquisitions to audiophile labels: I think 45rpmAudiophile said (or was trying to say) is merely that audiophile labels come w/ a relative guarantee of quality. In contrast, at least w/ regard to older presses, he has said what is true: they can be incredibly expensive compared to a Tone Poet, BN80, BN Classic, Impex, SC, AP, etc. and, even with those high prices, can be a minefield when it comes to grading and quality.
Also, fwiw, 45rpmaudiophile has been collecting records for more than a year. His YouTube channel has been up for about a year, and he’s garnered a very large audience