Bull Shannon
Well-Known Member
Finally got around to Promising Young Woman. It was good; I've avoided reading about it or even watching trailers, so I went in pretty fresh. I can see why some would be championing it and others would consider it a bit irresponsible or flip in its approach.
I will say I was pretty surprised how relatively tame her 'double life' turned out to be; as someone who's seen Hard Candy, Love Witch, and plenty other biting revenge stories in horror, it seemed a little underwhelming that her 'revenge' (up until she found Al) was to basically go 'boo! I'm sober!'
A lot of its effectiveness may boil down to perspective; early on I mentioned feeling the men are too obviously scummy, and it'd be easy for the average dude to refuse to see himself in the behavior depicted onscreen. I mean, when McLovin is doing lines off an album cover and going "Consider the Lobster? Consider my mind blown!" it's a little broadly drawn. But then, the movie's billed as a dark comedy, so perhaps those elements are supposed to be overtly silly? Either way, my wife said "nope," to all my nonsense and I think she's right: no matter how broadly or how outre you depict fictional bad male behavior, there's real men out there actually being like that.
A lot of its effectiveness may boil down to perspective; early on I mentioned feeling the men are too obviously scummy, and it'd be easy for the average dude to refuse to see himself in the behavior depicted onscreen. I mean, when McLovin is doing lines off an album cover and going "Consider the Lobster? Consider my mind blown!" it's a little broadly drawn. But then, the movie's billed as a dark comedy, so perhaps those elements are supposed to be overtly silly? Either way, my wife said "nope," to all my nonsense and I think she's right: no matter how broadly or how outre you depict fictional bad male behavior, there's real men out there actually being like that.