If you remember the film "Boyhood", there is that scene where Ethan Hawke's character gives his son a compilation of solo recordings from members of The Beatles that he dubbed "The Black Album". I'm sure everyone here knows that that was something that Ethan Hawke himself had actually done for his daughter Maya Hawke, and they incorporated it into the film. Always thought that was extremely cool.
The actual tracklist for that actual compilation was put out on the interwebs shortly after the film was released. I've always wanted to work up my version of "The Black Album", and I finally knocked it out last night. Hawke's version is really solid, so I used his as the initial framework for mine. Hawke's version of the compilation features 51 songs spread across 3 CDs, but the 3rd disc is only about 40 minutes. So I expanded my version out to 60 songs, dropping a few from his, adding some tracks, and shuffling a few things around. Paul and Wings get 22 songs, John gets 20, but I also included 2 of the songs that are attributed to The Beatles that were built out of John's demos ('Real Love' and 'Now & Then'). So that's basically 22 for him as well. George gets 12, and Ringo gets 4. George gets a bit more love from me and my expanded version, which is the biggest change from Hawke's version.
I didn't include certain John songs from "Plastic Ono Band" that I like because I felt they were a bit too harsh/dark in comparison to the rest of the material and the overall concept. I tried to keep Hawke's basic aesthetic, which was that these were solo songs from each of The Beatles that when put together could play like a killer Beatles collection. A set of songs where you could imagine them even recording them together if they had ever truly reformed. There are some exceptions though. Hawke excluded 'Working Class Hero', probably because it didn't fit his parameters. I put it on mine. Hard to see that one ever being recorded for a Beatles album, but it's just too strong of a song from John to not include.
This was a fun one to put together, and I'm glad I finally took the time to do so.