Vinyl Me Please Anthology

Same. I’ve stopped ordering live shows on vinyl because I usually had a CD copy that I could spin without getting up—multi disk changers rule. I love the shows I do have, when I ordered to Portland show, I got it for 50 bucks off amazon EU and they sent two, so came up more than even, but I honestly don’t spin it enough to justify paying 100 for it
For 50 bucks (I got my for roughly that amount on ebay IIRC), Portland is fine and there are some good sides to play. It is exhausting to play all the way through at 6lps.

The live releases during the Band's time are great on vinyl, even though its 3 lps, Europe 72 and Without A Net would be great introductions. I'm just worried that if they limited to 8 lps (who knows, I dont know exactly what they meant by the 4 lp numbers), this is going to not be worth it.
 
If you don’t really like them, then I’d say might not be worth it especially since the price tag might be big...but I have also somewhat unfairly written them off along with Phish and other jam bands but have been listening to way more classic rock and the like lately and have dug the studio albums I’ve been listening to a lot lately. Haven’t made the jump to live albums since I wouldn’t know where to begin...

Yeah I wouldnt either, which is why a curated box like this might just be perfect for me as opposed to a seasoned deadhead. Ive never especially loved live stuff on Vinyl anyway so a box 50/50 studio and live for them sounds kinda perfect.

The money Im not really as concerned about (within reason). Mine and my Wifes main vices are traveling and dining out, so with Covid this year its really freed up extra income big time. Shelf space, on the other hand, is a concern...
 
If you don’t really like them, then I’d say might not be worth it especially since the price tag might be big...but I have also somewhat unfairly written them off along with Phish and other jam bands but have been listening to way more classic rock and the like lately and have dug the studio albums I’ve been listening to a lot lately. Haven’t made the jump to live albums since I wouldn’t know where to begin...
Not sure if you're looking to listen to any Phish studio material, BUT their latest release Sigma Oasis is possibly their best release in over twenty years, and in my opinion, probably the best studio material that represents them now. Great ballads, high quality studio production, and studio jamming that is purely their sound.

I am the type of Phish fan that completely understands it is not for everyone, and admittedly it took me well over a year to even start to enjoy Phish after getting into the Dead. There's just soooo much stuff and it varies immensely by era, year, etc. But if you're looking to get a taste, I would say start with Sigma Oasis. The title track is catchy, Everything's Right, Steam, and Thread give you a taste of a live show in the studio, and Shade and Leaves are two of the best ballads they've ever recorded.

The fact that Pitchfork gave it a 6.5 should've made the front page of every major news publication.
 
Give either Europe '72 or Cornell 5/8/77 a shot. Or both--they're two distinct eras and both easily available on regular streaming services.
I'd also throw in One From The Vault and Red Rocks '78. But Europe '72 will always be my favorite, and Cornell '77 is a great SBD and approachable show for new listeners.

Edited to include the Red Rocks show because that's where I started. Was familiar with Workingman's Dead and American Beauty, but one day just decided to throw on that show and it hooked me immediately. The Bertha opener is so fun and it's a great setlist. Definitely check that one out.
 
Last edited:
Not sure if you're looking to listen to any Phish studio material, BUT their latest release Sigma Oasis is possibly their best release in over twenty years, and in my opinion, probably the best studio material that represents them now. Great ballads, high quality studio production, and studio jamming that is purely their sound.

I am the type of Phish fan that completely understands it is not for everyone, and admittedly it took me well over a year to even start to enjoy Phish after getting into the Dead. There's just soooo much stuff and it varies immensely by era, year, etc. But if you're looking to get a taste, I would say start with Sigma Oasis. The title track is catchy, Everything's Right, Steam, and Thread give you a taste of a live show in the studio, and Shade and Leaves are two of the best ballads they've ever recorded.

The fact that Pitchfork gave it a 6.5 should've made the front page of every major news publication.
I've never been a big Phish guy myself, but completely agree on their new album. Highly enjoyable.
 
7500 copies is a TON

180g x 8 = 1.44 kg/box
1.44 kg x 7500 = 10800 kg
10800 kg = 11.9 tons

;)

I don't have any Grateful Dead music, and have not really gotten into them. I like exploring musically, but buying a box set to explore is pretty crazy to me. I'll seek out an individual record for $20, but not fork out $300+ to discover new music. I felt the same about the Ghostly, was and still am curious about it, but not willing to pay that much for introduction.
 
180g x 8 = 1.44 kg/box
1.44 kg x 7500 = 10800 kg
10800 kg = 11.9 tons

;)

I don't have any Grateful Dead music, and have not really gotten into them. I like exploring musically, but buying a box set to explore is pretty crazy to me. I'll seek out an individual record for $20, but not fork out $300+ to discover new music. I felt the same about the Ghostly, was and still am curious about it, but not willing to pay that much for introduction.
Yea—agree. Ghostly is also just color versions of other pressings too so that one in particular wasn’t worth the price. Blue Note might be the only one so far IMO that was worth the price. Similar pressings of those albums in good shape would have cost me more than the box And one release has never been on vinyl.

I probably won’t buy this box unless it’s around $250 and includes some of the albums I was going to seek out on MoFi anyway. And if there’s something in there that’s exclusive, I’m sure I could get my money back if I decide to sell it later.
 
Yea—agree. Ghostly is also just color versions of other pressings too so that one in particular wasn’t worth the price. Blue Note might be the only one so far IMO that was worth the price. Similar pressings of those albums in good shape would have cost me more than the box And one release has never been on vinyl.

I probably won’t buy this box unless it’s around $250 and includes some of the albums I was going to seek out on MoFi anyway. And if there’s something in there that’s exclusive, I’m sure I could get my money back if I decide to sell it later.
Yeah, I have the Blue Note, and despite the issues, I like it. I am planning on getting the Herbie Hancock. Hopefully there is not too much overlap with what I have, and even then they should be better quality.
 
I'd also throw in One From The Vault and Red Rocks '78. But Europe '72 will always be my favorite, and Cornell '77 is a great SBD and approachable show for new listeners.

Edited to include the Red Rocks show because that's where I started. Was familiar with Workingman's Dead and American Beauty, but one day just decided to throw on that show and it hooked me immediately. The Bertha opener is so fun and it's a great setlist. Definitely check that one out.
Red Rocks 78 would make a solid vinyl release. And there were multiple Red Rocks shows that year, the reference is to 7/8/78.
 
Not sure The Grateful Dead is a rabbit hole I want to go down! If I wanted to try getting into them I'm not sure I need to go straight to an overpriced box set as a starting point but maybe I'm wrong, who knows? If it's under $100 I might think about it
 
Not sure The Grateful Dead is a rabbit hole I want to go down! If I wanted to try getting into them I'm not sure I need to go straight to an overpriced box set as a starting point but maybe I'm wrong, who knows? If it's under $100 I might think about it
For less than $100, go buy the Rhino pressings of Live/Dead, Workingman's Dead and American Beauty (should cost you about 60-75) and sample some live shows from different eras on the Internet Archive or streaming, and then go from there.
 
I opted for that Pacific Northwest Boxset and I love it. Definitely spin the CDs more than I would've just the Portland show, and yeah having a multi disk changer is the best for that. Same goes for Phish; while I enjoy Phish studio vinyl and the quality of them, the live stuff is hard to listen to in full on vinyl. I'd rather just listen to LivePhish CD releases without having to turn it over and lose the transitions.

At the end of the day, live jamming is real tough to translate to vinyl.
Yeah, I have the CD box set, and it gets way more playtime. With Phish I mainly use the Live Phish app, it is just easier to stream those shows. The only Phish vinyl I spin is a live one, which as a comp lends itself to spinning and flipping better than a full show I agree that the Red Rocks 78 is fantastic and is a fun, loose version of the band.
 
Not sure The Grateful Dead is a rabbit hole I want to go down! If I wanted to try getting into them I'm not sure I need to go straight to an overpriced box set as a starting point but maybe I'm wrong, who knows? If it's under $100 I might think about it
Agree it's probably not the best initial dive, but I'm in the same predicament as you. I might try to find the Rhino pressings as @wmeugene said and go from there. I have a lot of them as high-res FLAC as well right now and beefed up my digital setup at home but if its something I find myself listening to a ton, might just buy the albums individually.
 
Agree it's probably not the best initial dive, but I'm in the same predicament as you. I might try to find the Rhino pressings as @wmeugene said and go from there. I have a lot of them as high-res FLAC as well right now and beefed up my digital setup at home but if its something I find myself listening to a ton, might just buy the albums individually.
The Rhino Live Dead sounds really good. I have thr MoFis of the others I recommended and they of course sound amazing, but at 50 bucks a pop I don't know if I can recommend for someone jumping in.
 
Honestly, I just cannot imagine Dave or the Dead opening the vault to something juicy outside of a Dead.net release. With there being 4 studio and 4 live LPs, my guess is its some sort of assorted compilations. But I cannot see them doing a full show, which would be 5 LPs easily.

Smells like a box to get new listeners IMO, and VMP is probably a good place to start because there's a lot of FOMO and hype involved.
If there are 7,500 maybe it will also be sold via Dead.net, didn’t Ghostly sell copies of their box via their online store?
 
Back
Top