Vinyl Me Please Classics

I think VMP has spread themselves too thin with three tracks each month.

Can they do one great exclusive per month? Absolutely!
Can they do two? Maybe, sometimes, probably.
Can they do three? Doesnt look like it.

So the quality is balanced against what exclusives they can get and you have an off month like January where they are all ho-hum.

January's picks are across the board disappointing, but this is a really bad take. I've been a member for almost 5 years, and there are always going to be those months when a pick or two is less than exciting, but the curation is clearly very distinct (if occasionally curious) for each one. This way is far better than pre-Classics/RH&H when being hit-or-miss meant there was only a single album to focus on. It was much more obvious then that they actually couldn't always do 1 great album each month.

As other have said, the real problem is all of the other non-tracks business decisions they've made.
 
January's picks are across the board disappointing, but this is a really bad take. I've been a member for almost 5 years, and there are always going to be those months when a pick or two is less than exciting, but the curation is clearly very distinct (if occasionally curious) for each one. This way is far better than pre-Classics/RH&H when being hit-or-miss meant there was only a single album to focus on. It was much more obvious then that they actually couldn't always do 1 great album each month.

As other have said, the real problem is all of the other non-tracks business decisions they've made.

To each his own as far as takes go, I however gave 3 examples over 3 months in the last 5 months. So those months are pretty frequent.

It is better to have 3 ROTMS to be disapointed in, in the same month than just one, i guess.

My other point: When was the last month they did three great selections?
 
To each his own as far as takes go, I however gave 3 examples over 3 months in the last 5 months. So those months are pretty frequent.

It is better to have 3 ROTMS to be disapointed in, in the same month than just one, i guess.

My other point: When was the last month they did three great selections?

I think November was considered to be really highly rated across the board

QOTSA as the members whale
Brubeck as the big jazz dude
Slowthai is hugely acclaimed, that album was in the top 5 of the year in most British lists.

Its a pity that so many people haven't got them yet. January is a dumpster fire but then they’ve been weak for large parts of 2019. Even the classics is living off past glories, it might as well just be the jazz track at this stage, which is a huge turn off for me.
 
Last edited:
To each his own as far as takes go, I however gave 3 examples over 3 months in the last 5 months. So those months are pretty frequent.

It is better to have 3 ROTMS to be disapointed in, in the same month than just one, i guess.

My other point: When was the last month they did three great selections?

Unless you're citing a different post, your examples were from June, July, and upcoming January. And, yeah, completely agreed that everyone has their own threshold for what constitutes excitement or disappointment. I completely agree with you about both Phoenix and Dirty Projectors... and also find it amusing because we'd expect them to be solid on indie rock but that's the area where they consistently make baffling decisions. S-K turned out disappointing because of the band's shift, but I can see why VMP wanted it.

I'm the first to admit that I'm the wrong person to ask for an opinion on all 3 tracks combined because I just don't care about R&HH as much. I like some of them but it's largely not for me. I know some people have their complaints, and sure I'll spin some records more than others, but I really only disliked 1 of the Classics picks this year & thought another 2 were somewhat underwhelming. This year's Essentials had its duds, but I found the picks overall far better than the last couple years (2017 in particular being incredibly bad, imo).
 
I hate to say it but I feel like the anthologies are taking away from the Classics track. There are numerous records in the BN, Mtown, or Stax anthologies that would have been way more exciting than about 1/3 of the Classics of 2019. Maybe they were only able to get the rights for a box set but I don't know...
 
I hate to say it but I feel like the anthologies are taking away from the Classics track. There are numerous records in the BN, Mtown, or Stax anthologies that would have been way more exciting than about 1/3 of the Classics of 2019. Maybe they were only able to get the rights for a box set but I don't know...

As a jazz, soul/r&b and blues lover, there is literally a limitless archive of superlative music to select 12 records a year from 1960 to 1980. That’s two decades of quite possibly the most fertile and creative time period of music. It’s a treasure trove, for real. Getting licensing rights will be an issue for larger labels, but it’s not always a hindrance. On the flip side, there are labels that would actually love the exposure. Some reissue companies have tapped directly into this market because they had the foresight, vision, taste, and most importantly, the knowledge. A perfect example of this is Numero Group. Numero Group has hipped mainstream America to so many labels, scenes, and music from Black enclaves that most of their audience was unaware of. Everyone knows Motown, Stax, and Blue Note already. They’re literally 3 of the most successful labels in their respective fields, so the idea that releasing box sets from those labels is making the pickings slim or less exciting for the Classics track doesn’t really hold up imo. There is so much music out there! Though I don't disagree that some titles in those sets would have been better than a lot of the 2019 Classics titles.

What the anthology sets might be doing to VMP is maybe making them lose focus on everything else, like not ensuring that a website migration at the busiest shopping time of the year would work before executing it, or shipping out our damn records in time. Still doesn’t explain their lack professionalism, transparency or clear communication. Honestly, VMP acts like an abusive partner. They’ll ignore and gaslight you, then when you speak up about the mistreatment, they’ll send you a long email that explains nothing, then close out the long email with a heart emoji. Nothing will actually change about the way they treat you or their behavior either...lol
 
Last edited:
As a jazz, soul/r&b and blues lover, there is literally a limitless archive of superlative music to select 12 records a year from 1960 to 1980. That’s two decades of quite possibly the most fertile and creative time period of music. It’s a treasure trove, for real. Getting licensing rights will be an issue for larger labels, but it’s not always a hindrance. On the flip side, there are labels that would actually love the exposure. Some reissue companies have tapped directly into this market because they had the foresight, vision, taste, and most importantly, the knowledge. A perfect example of this is Numero Group. Numero Group has hipped mainstream America to so many labels, scenes, and music from Black enclaves that most of their audience was unaware of. Everyone knows Motown, Stax, and Blue Note already. They’re literally 3 of the most successful labels in their respective fields, so the idea that releasing box sets from those labels is making the pickings slim or less exciting for the Classics track doesn’t really hold up imo. There is so much music out there! Though I don't disagree that some titles in those sets would have been better than a lot of the 2019 Classics titles.

What the anthology sets might be doing to VMP is maybe making them lose focus on everything else, like not ensuring that a website migration at the busiest shopping time of the year would work before executing it, or shipping out our damn records in time. Still doesn’t explain their lack professionalism, transparency or clear communication. Honestly, VMP acts like an abusive partner. They’ll ignore and gaslight you, then when you speak up about the mistreatment, they’ll send you a long email that explains nothing, then close out the long email with a heart emoji. Nothing will actually change about the way they treat you or their behavior either...lol
I think the major impact on stretching thin is that they've had one person curating the three Classic Anthologies along with the Classics track (and doing amateur customer service on reddit).
 
So I finally received my BB King yesterday (still awaiting the rest), but I noticed when taking it out of the jacket that the inner sleeve doesn't have QRP's logo/labels.

I've never had a release that was pressed at QRP come with a generic poly inner sleeve.

Anyone else see this in their packages?
 
So I finally received my BB King yesterday (still awaiting the rest), but I noticed when taking it out of the jacket that the inner sleeve doesn't have QRP's logo/labels.

I've never had a release that was pressed at QRP come with a generic poly inner sleeve.

Anyone else see this in their packages?

Was the record wrapped in that loose plastic bag they usually use?
 
So I finally received my BB King yesterday (still awaiting the rest), but I noticed when taking it out of the jacket that the inner sleeve doesn't have QRP's logo/labels.

I've never had a release that was pressed at QRP come with a generic poly inner sleeve.

Anyone else see this in their packages?
I noticed that as well. Feels and looks exactly like the QRP/MoFi ones though just minus the watermark so I’m okay with jt
 
Was the record wrapped in that loose plastic bag they usually use?
It was, though there are a few plants that will package like that these days...

I noticed that as well. Feels and looks exactly like the QRP/MoFi ones though just minus the watermark so I’m okay with jt

Yeah I'm fine with the sleeve, but I'm more questioning whether this was actually pressed at QRP.

I'll also add that the surface has a good deal of non-audible scuffing and finger prints; which adds to my suspicion. It could just be a poorly handled packaging job during the holiday rush, but I have ~50 albums pressed at QRP and this certainly looks like an outlier.
 
It was, though there are a few plants that will package like that these days...



Yeah I'm fine with the sleeve, but I'm more questioning whether this was actually pressed at QRP.

I'll also add that the surface has a good deal of non-audible scuffing and finger prints; which adds to my suspicion. It could just be a poorly handled packaging job during the holiday rush, but I have ~50 albums pressed at QRP and this certainly looks like an outlier.
I noticed the scuffing as well but I actually just got AP’s Time Out which I believe is pressed at QRP as well and it had the same non audible scuffing that I saw on BB. All that aside I think BB sounds fantastic so it fits the QRP bill
 
I noticed the scuffing as well but I actually just got AP’s Time Out which I believe is pressed at QRP as well and it had the same non audible scuffing that I saw on BB. All that aside I think BB sounds fantastic so it fits the QRP bill

That's more a factor of Ryan K Smith's excellent work - and it was definitely his cut, no question there! (y)
 
Should have done Sextant or Thrust. Oh well. If they really want to fuck with the program, do some of the Mwandishi records in the Kozmigrov orbit. Norman Connors...Eddie Henderson...bet the tapes are long gone for those.

Eddie Henderson's excellent LP, "Heritage" was set to be in the Blue Note Anthology box set, but Bobby Hutcherson's "Montara" was picked instead by VMP. Point is, BN still has the tapes. I've got an OG "Heritage," but still would have been cool to have one of my all-time fav joints in the BN box.

 
Eddie Henderson's excellent LP, "Heritage" was set to be in the Blue Note Anthology box set, but Bobby Hutcherson's "Montara" was picked instead by VMP. Point is, BN still has the tapes. I've got an OG "Heritage," but still would have been cool to have one of my all-time fav joints in the BN box.


His early stuff is incredible! Realization is probably my favorite, but I don't have Heritage yet. It's been on my list for a while and copies look quite expensive!! Congrats on that OG!
 
Back
Top