I can’t believe VMP actually is asking for records back. Aside from the legality, I would be offended of how they value a customer’s time.
I would respond by saying “I’m not your employee. I will not box up 20 records on my own time, and make it to the post office using my gas, to stand in line during the busiest shipping season, during business hours when I normally make money. You can fuck right off.
It looks like the estimated market value for these records appears to be about $65 dollars each. Given that I do now legally own these records, VMP is welcome to purchase 24 copies for $1560 + actual shipping cost. Oh, and I only ship once a month, so they will ship by the end of the year, unless of course they’d like to pay an additional $5 per record for expedited shipping. So for a cool $1680 + shipping they can have them all in the mail by Wednesday.”