Well yeah I mean, what’s the alternative? VMP give a $35 credit for each extra copy of the record you send back? Because not only would that be disastrously bad from a financial standpoint, but even that would be “lowballing” it, considering secondhand prices will almost certainly be higher. Honestly, I really do think that most people in the vinyl community either have no interest in flipping, and/or no knowledge of how to. Is there a potential for more money to be made on the secondhand market? Sure, but it’s not like EVERYBODY got 25 copies, some people only got one or two more than what they ordered, so for them, a raffle entry is likely the better option. A free turntable, $500 in credit, a year’s subscription to all 3 tracks, etc. is a VERY hefty return on investment when the investment is “records you didn’t pay for or plan on having in the first place”, and while VMP could never compete with potential secondhand market value, I think this is the best way to handle such a fuck up
Also, of all the conspiracies I’ve seen here, “VMP has a gang of paid staffers who they instruct to downvote Reddit comments” is by far the craziest one. Maybe people downvote you because you call everyone with a different opinion a stan, bootlicker, or undercover employee?