I have watched all the Scream movies over the past month or so...
Scream (96) - I had seen this one before, years ago, but it stayed pretty fresh and fun and gorier than I remembered on this rewatch. It's a classic. The meta nature of the franchise works best in this original form, and it's the one that balances the funny and brutal creepy tones perfectly. Also best opening sequence in all the Screams.
Scream 2 - a pretty damn solid follow-up. The opening sequence here is less great than the first, but still pretty funny and wild. Everything that follows feels pretty logical as a sequel, even when it's kind of dumb. The reveal at the end was the worst part of it for me. Part of the fun of these movies is to try and unravel who the killer(s) are, and this one how it all winds up is just...bad to me.
Scream 3 - again, it almost does feel logical to follow up the meta nature of Scream with them going full-tilt into Hollywood itself. Whether or not it totally works is up to you. I think some of works, but largely it forgoes the fun and creepiness of the first one (and the second) for a goofier movie. The mystery isn't as compelling, and the reveal sucks.
Scream 4 - I saw this one in the theater, so I remember a lot of it, but I don't remember people enjoying it that much. Although I do find a lot of it weirdly nostalgic for 2011, it does almost feel more weirdly dated than the first one. That said, I will defend this one. I think the new characters are good, the mystery is a lot of fun, and the reveal is actually great. I don't get the hate. Is some of it...less good than the originals? Sure, but to me it easily beats out 3 and almost rivals 2. The opening sequence is a bit too silly for me though.
Scream (22) - I was so excited for this that I guess I should have known it could not live up to the hype I had set for myself. But honestly for big chunks of its running time, I was confused why this was so well received. A lot of it did seem fan-service-y, but it's also making fun of the concept of being fan service-y? Doesn't fully come together. I thought some of the writing was really bad in this one. But, honestly, by the end I was having a lot of fun. The climax is great - even if it's too reminiscent of another one - but that's the point? The reveal is kinda strange, but I liked it overall because it plays with your expectations so much throughout the whole movie. Some of the choices I think are just dumb, but it's fun by the end - and also the goriest since the first one. They really toned down the violence in 2 and 3 especially. I guess I'm interested in whatever the next one will be called, but I don't necessarily think it'll ever match the first one for me. That's the best one, easily. Oh the opening sequence here is really nothing special. Didn't find it fun or intense much at all.