I went and saw Babylon today, alone, and in a theater with only 3 other people in it. I know the movie has gotten wild reactions, with a ton of critics hating on it. But seeing it for myself, it only reaffirms the problem I have with critical consensus. This movie is definitely A LOT, by design. Whether or not you can hang with that, I guess, is up to you. Maybe you’d check out in the first half hour when things are just off the rails excessive, gross, and ugly. But I believe there is a greater purpose here.
This is not a love letter to cinema, or Hollywood. So much of it is a condemnation of the rot in the industry, and the depravity that exists surrounding it. But it also asks the question of is it worth it? There’s way more nuance to it than the way people have described it. By the end, I am left thinking a lot about things. I don’t think it’s super simple at all. I think there are a lot of layers here and some incredible, breathtaking filmmaking. It’s not perfect, sure. But it’s nowhere close to being a bad film. I enjoyed the hell of it personally. It left me with so much to chew on. But I was also fully engaged the entire 3 hr runtime.
Other movies this year have made smarter choices when choosing to make a movie about the industry’s awfulness (see: Nope), but Babylon definitely succeeds in what it’s set out to do.