Eh, theory not law. Can't win 'em all.
I just put on UTB and haven't moved much. Silver Lining is great and a couple other tracks are good tracks, but man if I never hear Dejalo or The Moneymaker or Dreamworld or Smoke Detector again I won't be too sad. Maybe it's just the bigger production I don't care for - I generally put on Rilo Kiley for the lyrics or the emotion of it. The writing is there is just gets washed out by the production decisions. Obviously all just opinions. I tend to like Jenny's more simply produced stuff too.
Edit: I think 15 is a good example. I really think the lyrical content of 15 is whip smart, good storytelling, evocative, all the good stuff. The weird faux country and vocal decisions just make it a much harder listen for me.