The Official Needles and Grooves 1001 Album Generator Project

MyWifeHatesTrain said:
7/3/24
View attachment 207569
Radiohead - Amnesiac



www.allmusic.com

Amnesiac - Radiohead | Album | AllMusic

Amnesiac by Radiohead released in 2001. Find album reviews, track lists, credits, awards and more at AllMusic.
www.allmusic.com www.allmusic.com
Click to expand...

This album is excellent but it will always play second fiddle to Kid A (and it should). Still, I applaud the band for realizing that they were on such a roll that they needed to officially release these extra track as an official release.
 
dbarila said:
I think I'm in the minority who enjoys this album slightly more than Kid A.
Click to expand...

I don’t think it’s as much of a minority as you think. This album is definitely more accessible initially and has always had people who prefer it to Kid A which can be a bit more challenging. I’ve always felt the pay off with Kid A was much greater and that the core songs are just stronger but I can definitely see the other point of view.
 
dbarila said:
Correct that I'm a minority? Or correct that this album is slightly better?
Click to expand...
The minority. It feels like a contrarian take.

I am not saying you’re being disingenuous I just think some folks have an affinity for going against the grain. Both albums are excellent and it would be interesting if Kid A didn’t exist how Amnesiac would stack up against the rest of their discography but you can read a review that doesn’t mention Amnesiac at all while Kid A is always the main discussion point of Amnesiac.
 
TenderLovingKiller® said:
The minority. It feels like a contrarian take.

I am not saying you’re being disingenuous I just think some folks have an affinity for going against the grain. Both albums are excellent and it would be interesting if Kid A didn’t exist how Amnesiac would stack up against the rest of their discography but you can read a review that doesn’t mention Amnesiac at all while Kid A is always the main discussion point of Amnesiac.
Click to expand...
I was careful to say that I enjoy it more than Kid A. Kid A is obviously great and I enjoy that one as well. I just really like "Pyramid Song" and "Like Spinning Plates" and the dark, brooding version of Morning Bell.
 
TenderLovingKiller® said:
The minority. It feels like a contrarian take.

I am not saying you’re being disingenuous I just think some folks have an affinity for going against the grain. Both albums are excellent and it would be interesting if Kid A didn’t exist how Amnesiac would stack up against the rest of their discography but you can read a review that doesn’t mention Amnesiac at all while Kid A is always the main discussion point of Amnesiac.
Click to expand...
Most reviews of Kid A were written before Amnesiac existed and they are intertwined, so after the fact it makes sense to talk about both.

Seems like Rolling Stone thinks Amnesiac is better but I haven’t finished the review yet. It could have a M Night Shyamalan twist for all I know.
 
MyWifeHatesTrain said:
Eldest is over tonight. I don’t foresee that happening to night (might have to do it soon though) - I don’t think I even ever listened to the bonus disc.
Click to expand...
The bonus disc is a little meh. Ironically enough the only time I listened to it is when my Schiit Mani was on the frtiz (as I had mentioned in the Darlington thread) and at that point I thought it was just a weird artistic choice to have the music so heavily panned to one channel
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top