Political Discussion

This whole thing is yikes, but seriously a lot of people need to leave Texas before it gets a lot worse. I just don't think democracy is strong enough to make that a fight worth having anymore. It's time to protect loved ones and leave these hate filled areas where they are literally trying to deny existence and usher in overt fascist authoritarianism. And Texas seceding is the least concerning thing here, accept of course that those who stay will lose federal protections and be in a really bad place unless they act before it's too late.
 
Too easy though, right?
1) establishes dangerous precedents for any state or region or community to do the same
2) creates massive disruption of access to natural resources
3) completely redraws ports/points of entry into the US for commerce and/or immigration/refugees
4) abandons current citizens who cannot leave for a variety of reasons
5) not a lawyer here, but (I would imagine) potentially invalidates/reimagines a lot of federal law
6) immense economic hits to GDP, etc.

Sure, cut TX loose, and then you have an oil-rich theocracy at our door.

I don't think I agree that this all adds up to a fight "not worth having." The US is dangerously unstable, but I don't think the solution is giving way to the impulsive whims of the most radical actors who pop up at any given moment.

It’s also not entirely clear if most national, or even international law, even allows for or recognises secession in the vast majority of cases. That’s before you get to the reality of how would Texas enforce any theoretical secession if the federal state refused to recognise it.
 
Too easy though, right?
1) establishes dangerous precedents for any state or region or community to do the same
2) creates massive disruption of access to natural resources
3) completely redraws ports/points of entry into the US for commerce and/or immigration/refugees
4) abandons current citizens who cannot leave for a variety of reasons
5) not a lawyer here, but (I would imagine) potentially invalidates/reimagines a lot of federal law
6) immense economic hits to GDP, etc.

Sure, cut TX loose, and then you have an oil-rich theocracy at our door.

I don't think I agree that this all adds up to a fight "not worth having." The US is dangerously unstable, but I don't think the solution is giving way to the impulsive whims of the most radical actors who pop up at any given moment.

I used to agree with this take, but I don't anymore. For democracy to function people both need to negotiate in good faith and accept the results. The Republican party hasn't been willing to do that in years, and since Regan they've pulled the Democrats to a place of complete ineptitude. It took me spending the last decade researching modern political economies and the shifting behaviors and attitudes of Americans since WWII for me to start looking at the science without my desires of how I wish it was to distort my interpretation of the data.

Democratic means have failed and without making plans to safeguard the freedoms we've gained in the past 70 years, we'll lose those too. By all means exhaust those avenues until the end, but plan now for them to fall, don't wait until it's to late and the human cost is devastating. It'll be worse for those left behind if we don't plan to help them now. I'm not willing to go head first into another civil war. Instead, we need to offer relocation services for those marginalized folks who want to live in places where they will have rights. Economics should not be the driving factor. That's what leads to war.

And, again, precedent only matters in a functioning democracy, of which, America is no longer. Even conservative leaning publications and economic institutes have acknowledged in their research that America is no longer a fully functional democratic society.
 
But the issue that remains is that secession is a geographic solution to an ideological problem. "Republican" isn't a state that can remove itself from the Union (particularly when it sees itself as the "real" America). Suppose Texas could actually leave the US, does that not just create a second front in the culture wars?
I'm not advocating for secession as a solution to the problem. I don't think it will end the wider spread culture war and issue of fascism in America, which goes way beyond Texas. What I'm saying is that I'm not willing to go to war with them to stop it, I don't think democratic means will solve the problem, and I think contingency plans to take care of the people most negatively effected need to be put into place. By not preparing for their willingness to cheat their way to power and enact violence on marginalized peoples, we are condemning them to live in a place that would see them as either second class citizens or as subhuman and our democratic institutions to the graveyard. This to me is the same logic as saying if you don't like things the way they are then go and vote. When we've been voting and things keep getting worse. We can no longer rely on the democratic institutions to save us in their current state because they have been dismantled and sabotaged by Republicans and head-in-the-sand Democrats. So what I'm saying is that it isn't enough and when one of the two major political parties is going all in on the narrative that they reject the results of elections, want to undo voting rights, and condemn as abnormal those in the LGBTQIA+ community, then there is no reasoning with them. There is no middle ground or negotiating, in a word, no democracy. So, in order to save what remains of it, it would be better without Texas. Federally the Republican's would probably never control the house, senate, or presidency again, and a progressive party could emerge that served as a real opposition to the corporate rule that we've been living under. Fascism doesn't emerge in a bubble. And the Democrats are guilty of making peoples lives worse too. People have to have good lives and hope in the future for them to live at peace, and that means doing things in a way that we provide a basic standard of living that secures a future for the planet and the next generations. Put that experiment to the test and I think the culture war will wither, but it's not possible with the current political climate and Republicans in power.
 
Last edited:
More fuckery from PA.

Sally's posted this and then did a dirty delete. What a vile piece of 💩! She is getting utterly dragged. It's glorious. Grab yer popcorn and head on over to Sally’s Valley BoysView attachment 142843

Facebook is full of garbage about Juneteenth being a holiday. For example, someone shared this screenshot on another form of what kind of replies they were seeing to a post about their city hall being closed for the holiday.


1655755249131.png


The holiday was also met with scenes like this across the country.



 
Last edited:
Typing on the phone is hard with autocorrect.

Hahaha! It’s such a common mistake at this point that, without aiming it at you per se, it kinda needs correcting. I’ve seen people put succeed rather than secede in serious pieces at this stage 👀

It isn’t my biggest pet peeve though, that’s people saying mute point rather than moot point, that one really pisses me off 😂
 
Hahaha! It’s such a common mistake at this point that, without aiming it at you per se, it kinda needs correcting. I’ve seen people put succeed rather than secede in serious pieces at this stage 👀

It isn’t my biggest pet peeve though, that’s people saying mute point rather than moot point, that one really pisses me off 😂
It bugs me too! And I've corrected both in so many papers. But I swear I can't write without typos in everything on my phone. The other common one that I see frequently is capitol vs capital...
 
It bugs me too! And I've corrected both in so many papers. But I swear I can't write without typos in everything on my phone. The other common one that I see frequently is capitol vs capital...

The one that makes me laugh was when I was training to be a barrister a lot of my fellow students referred to their future role as council rather than counsel…

Perhaps they just wanted run a municipality, who knows…
 
It bugs me too! And I've corrected both in so many papers. But I swear I can't write without typos in everything on my phone. The other common one that I see frequently is capitol vs capital...

On another point I think capitol is only present in American English, I don’t think that’s a word we use in our English. You use it to refer to Parliament, in terms of the chamber/building, as opposed to the gathering if I understand correctly?
 
On another point I think capitol is only present in American English, I don’t think that’s a word we use in our English. You use it to refer to Parliament, in terms of the chamber/building, as opposed to the gathering if I understand correctly?

Is it a case of color vs colour or center vs centre? Or do the words have different meanings.
 
Is it a case of color vs colour or center vs centre? Or do the words have different meanings.
In American English, it's the building that governments meet in to conduct official state/federal business, or capitalized it's specifically the building in DC. Opposed to the capitalization of a letter or the economic coagulation of value.

Might be other uses I'm not remembering?

Since I'm a political economist they both get used in papers I assign frequently and by students often incorrectly.
 
Is it a case of color vs colour or center vs centre? Or do the words have different meanings.

No we have capital the same as you do. In that it can be used in terms of primary such as a capital city/letter or alternatively money. Capitol, if I understand it refers to the buildings in which your chambers sit. We don’t use that word at all, our chambers would be in Houses of Parliament.
 
In American English, it's the building that governments meet in to conduct official state/federal business, or capitalized it's specifically the building in DC. Opposed to the capitalization of a letter or the economic coagulation of value.

Might be other uses I'm not remembering?

Capital I thought was a city the government resides in? So Capitol refers to the the building. Interesting.
 
Back
Top